Thursday, 16th July 2026 Cardiff 24° · Clear sky
NationCymru A news service by the people of Wales, for the people of Wales.

Opinion

Speak The Truth

By Mark Mansfield
Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer picks up UK US trade deal papers dropped by US President Donald Trump. Photo Stefan Rousseau/PA Wire

Ben Wildsmith

If you need any confirmation of the UK’s place in the world, consider David Lammy’s remarks last week about Donald Trump’s intentions regarding the Israeli war on Iran.

‘A window now exists to achieve a diplomatic solution, something the UK has called for since the start of this conflict.’

That was on Friday, so less of a window than an arrow slit, as it turned out.

Not that the UK is alone in its irrelevance. Lammy was joined by his French and German counterparts for talks with Iran on Friday. Trump’s response to that was to tell journalists, ‘Nah, they didn’t help, Iran doesn’t want to speak to Europe. They want to speak to us. Europe is not going to be able to help on this one.’

So, the two-week space for negotiations that Trump teased earlier in the day was a unilateral US deception that wasn’t shared with European allies.

As Keir Starmer scrabbled round Trump’s feet, picking up papers for a supposed trade deal, he was out of the loop and disregarded on the real matters of state.

[mid-content-banner]

Bright side

On Sunday, after America had dropped six ‘bunker-buster’ bombs and 30 Tomahawk missiles on Iran’s nuclear facilities, the UK government was looking on the bright side. Business Secretary, Jonathan Reynolds, told the BBC, ‘I wanted a different way to obtain this, but I cannot pretend to you that the prevention of Iran having a nuclear weapon is anything other than [in] the interests of this country. This is very different to what we saw with the invasion of Iraq … I think stability for the region would come about through an agreement where Iran would acknowledge that, because of its behaviour, no country in that theatre or the wider world would be able to countenance it having nuclear weapons.’

It is interesting to note the reference to the Iraq War here. Those in the Labour government who were around in 2003 are experiencing painful déjà vu as events move around them that could lead to their undoing.

Reynolds found himself dancing on the head of a pin when questioned by LBC’s Lewis Goodall.

The UK, he confirmed, had sought de-escalation and a diplomatic solution but now that Iran had been bombed it welcomed that outcome.

UK forces had not been involved and he wouldn’t speculate on whether they would have been if America had requested them. Now, he was ‘very clear’ that missile attacks on Israel should stop so that there is no need for further ‘preventative action’.

The faction that has gained supremacy in the Labour Party has never really understood why people were so upset about the Iraq War.  The endless ‘third way’ doublespeak that facilitated the Blair government in entrenching Thatcherite economics at the expense of post-industrial Britain just didn’t work when it came to the wholescale slaughter of Iraqis and the wider mayhem that provoked.

[lower-mid-content-banner]

Restraint

The UK represented by our government is without moral content. Whilst the Blair version was at least content to own its role as the bully’s mate, Starmer’s administration seeks to present itself as a force for restraint and peace whilst failing to demand either from the nations that count.

Would it not be liberating and refreshing to live in a nation that could look at circumstances like these and give voice to the obvious facts that all of us can see? Israel is indisputably running a fully-functional secret nuclear programme which no international body is allowed to inspect. Israel is expanding its territory into the West Bank, Syria, and Lebanon. Israel assassinated eight Iranian officials in diplomatic premises in Damascus. Israel has fired first in each of the exchanges of missiles with Iran.

Iran is a sickeningly repressive regime, and it very clearly has hostile intent towards Israel. For our government, however, to behave as if it is the primary threat to humanity in the region, whilst ignoring all of the above, and the ongoing carnage in Gaza, is cruelly absurd.

Busted flush

The UK is a busted flush on the international stage. It does as it is told whilst clinging to a fantasy of influence that long ago evaporated. It is no longer even required to throw a veil of old-world respectability over American belligerence as it did over Iraq.

If Cymru is to signal its distinctness next year by electing a Plaid Cymru-led government, then we should find the independence of spirit that has characterised the Irish response to events in the Middle East.

We have no power, that is the bald truth of it. Instead, we should recapture our dignity and be a nation that speaks the truth.

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Get more trusted Welsh news

Choose Nation.Cymru as a preferred source in Google News to see more of our journalism.

Choose Nation.Cymru as a preferred source in Google News

39 comments

Amir

Time to let USA go along with their new best friends: the Zionists. Best for UK to stay out of this cesspit. But they won't.

Reply
Mab Meirion

The Lone Ranger and Tonto were riding down the line... Fixing no ones troubles but acting like thing's is just fine...' @Lemmy not Lammy

Reply
Mab Meirion

Every Picture Tells a Story... Twmp did that on purpose... Amphora: an empty vessel that can't stand up by its self... We had a bomb like that, two in fact Tallboy and Grand Slam, 'superior to the yank and carried on a Lancaster...apart from control surfaces on the fins... What would it do to the San Andreas Fault I wonder...

Reply
Mab Meirion

12 F-35 bought to drop little 'buckets of sunshine' on a European battlefield...the attention span of the Masters of War is measured in dollars, Jeff you have some reading to do, if you want a book list just ask...a lot to 'grapple' with...

Reply
Maesglas

Well said Ben. Starmer shows us, in this as with many other issues, he is the “anything goes” PM. Delusion, evasion, and obfuscation from our government who will roll over to anything that Trump says. This is the very time we need a leader with moral substance ready to stand against sleepwalking into global conflict and prevent war.

Reply
Amir

So you are taking the side of the zionists who in the name of October 7th have annihilated most of Ghazza and its citizens and called it justifiable homicide rather than genocide? And these are meant to somehow be the good guys? Are you for serious? Forget history.

Reply
Barton

This is not about taking sides but looking at facts. It takes two to tango and both sides have done terrible things to each other. But Iran has been directly responsible in creating proxy terror groups and they have carried out terrorist acts across the world for decades. If anyone is taking sides it’s the author of this article - are you also siding with them?

Reply
Undecided

The Netanyahu and Khamenei regimes are as bad as each other; but if all this results in the demise of the latter I won’t shed a tear. It will take a bit longer to catch up with Netanyahu; but it will in the end. It nearly always does. That’s the lesson from history.

Reply
Amir

Yes, I agree with the author. The zionists have not shown themselves to be any different in how they regard others different to themselves. They consider themselves to be better than others. They are after all the chosen people. Anyone who thinks they are better then a random person next to them is a racist.

Reply

In reply to Amir

Barton

You talk about Israel’s actions but conveniently stay silent on Iran’s complicity with terrorism! You complain about racism but then say “they” are the “chosen people” - is “they” a particular racial group of people you are referring to, perhaps?

Reply

In reply to Barton

Amir

The zionists claim to be the chosen people. Have you read this opinion article. Go back and read paragraph 15 of this opinion article

Reply

In reply to Amir

Barton

There was no mention of the term “chosen people” in paragraph 15 or anywhere in that article which you refer to. YOU have used that term and I suggest you take ownership of it - nice distraction though! It’s interesting how you accuse others of racism (‘pot calling kettle black’ perhaps?)

Reply

In reply to Barton

Amir

Paragraph 15 refers to the second part of your sentence.

Reply

In reply to Amir

Barton

You seem to be clutching at straws trying to wiggle out of your original statement about “chosen people” – which you may know is a very loosely veiled term for a specific racial group (hint: beginning with J) and keep referring me back to the article even though that term is not mentioned there!

Reply

In reply to Barton

Amir

I have no issue with saying chosen people. If someone wants to become a muslim or christian, it is a quick process. Not so one other Mosaic religion. You said I was silent on Iran. I said read paragraph 15.

Reply

In reply to Amir

Barton

Ah so this IS about religion and race for you! I thought so…next time you accuse others of racism, maybe you should also think about your own views. Personally I don’t agree with most religions - however if your issue is with a particular religious/racial group, there are far right/far left websites you can go on who would gladly have you join them. Unless Plaid Cymru and Labour subscribe to that view as well??

Reply

In reply to Barton

Amir

This conflict is all about religion.

Reply

In reply to Amir

Barton

It’s also about whether an ancient Semitic group of people have a right to return to what they claim is their homeland after an extended period of absence - which the Iranian regime does not acknowledge and wants to destroy. It’s also a power struggle of regional dominance - which has been going on in the region even before the West existed! What is not acceptable is to associate/blame all people of the Jewish religion with what Israel does or does not do!

Reply

In reply to Barton

Tucker

Whose blaming Jewish people? Zionism was founded by an atheist

Reply

In reply to Amir

Barton

Don’t hide behind veiled works like Mosaic, Chosen People and Zionists!

Reply

In reply to Barton

Amir

Mosaic simply refers to the religions originating from Moses peace be upon him. They all see Jerusalem as one of their holiest sites. I don't think you should be dictating what I say. This is a comments section and the discourse between enlightens all of us. There are reasons certain words are used and others are not used. Words have significance and there are rich , beautiful and strong. But that is all they are.

Reply

In reply to Amir

Barton

I find it curious how you wish ‘peace upon’ Moses but not the Jewish people - who are from that region too

Reply

In reply to Barton

Amir

Peace be upon all the Jews.

Reply

In reply to Amir

Barton

May your blessing of peace be upon all in the Middle East as well 🙏

Reply

In reply to Barton

Mab Meirion

Dick Barton Special Agent who remembers the 1940's and 50's radio, TV and B movies

Reply

In reply to Barton

Roger

Yes, Israel's Jewish population is diverse and includes Jews from various parts of the world. While the majority of Israeli Jews are of European or Middle Eastern/North African descent, many have immigrated from countries like Ethiopia, Russia, and the Americas. This diverse influx of Jewish immigrants has shaped Israel's cultural landscape.

Reply

In reply to Barton

Roger Harris

The chosen people. It says so in the Bible and they were the ones who had Christ crucified by proxy. Arab-Israeli Conflict: This is a central and ongoing conflict, with roots in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, escalating after the establishment of Israel in 1948. There have been numerous wars, uprisings (intifadas), and periods of intense violence between Israel and various Arab nations, as well as internal conflicts within Palestinian territories.

Reply

In reply to Roger Harris

Barton

Oh dear it’s wives tales like that which perpetuate hatred between groups of people in the world - and the cause of many deaths and wars. The bible did not blame a whole group ‘the chosen people’ on the death of Christ (who was born and died a Jew incidentally) so shame on you for your carpet-bombing of blame!

Reply
Steve D.

Bombs don't get what you want in the Middle East - they just cause more death and destruction in the future. The Americans just don't see it and believe they can just force their views on anyone. Yes, the nuclear capabilities of Iran may be smashed now but you can bet your arse the Iranians will go hell for broke to develop a bomb now. As for the UK's role - no one gives a monkeys. For Cymru in an independent future our voice would be a far stronger one as part of a united European voice. Europeans together have far more clout than they would on their own.

Reply
John Ellis

A bit of credit to Trump, I suppose, because, being the sort of ghoul that he is, he has no inhibitions about saying it as he sees it. Whereas his predecessors in the White House almost certainly thought pretty much the same as Trump, but they were just too genteel and courteous to say it out loud!

Reply
Amir

I walking back to my hotel with my colleagues in London as few years ago. A man starting shouting racial abuse at me. My colleague said , "he is just saying out loud what other people really think about you". I hate racists and those that admire them.

Reply
John Ellis

If you've formed the notion that I'd number myself among Trump's admirers, you could hardly be further from the truth!

Reply

In reply to John Ellis

Amir

Then why give him any credit? He is a racist, misogynistic sociopath.

Reply

In reply to Amir

John Ellis

I don't see it as 'credit'. Here at Westminster we've recently had a succession of plausible and honey-tongued dissemblers in positions of power. We even, briefly, had one of that sort in Wales. Trump is at least unambiguous: he doesn't hide his inclination to govern as a populist autocrat, very much in the mould of mid-20th century European fascist leaders. At least, with him, we know what manner of man he is. Whereas with, say, Johnson here, most voters really didn't. Same goes for Gething!

Reply

In reply to John Ellis

Amir

He is ambiguous. He said there will a 2 week pause, then measured his stick and realised it had got smaller so he brought the attack forward.

Reply

In reply to Amir

John Ellis

No argument from me about that. He's utterly chaotic and wholly self-serving in all that he does. But at least he's openly and shamelessly venal. The politicians whom I despise the most are those who purport to have ethical principles and then, once in power, demonstrate that they don't. And it seems to me that there are rather too many of that sort in contemporary British politics.

Reply

In reply to John Ellis

Mab Meirion

He is demented, filtering his own grotesque being through the prism of the likes of Steve Miller and Bannon and the rest, John he has never turned a cheek in his life (beyond a mistress)... These are forces beyond the likes of an Arch Oil Man in modern times....since the last burning at the stake...a 'fight to the death'

Reply
Mab Meirion

You ask a certain group why they emigrated to our Coast, purely to get away from you and yours Amir is the answer every time...

Reply
Mab Meirion

Chosen People...Matthew 22:14 if you need help ask the leader of the Welsh Tories... The Catlicks, when I got away from them age 16 I chose myself and I've been true to myself to this day... Stop coming out with drivel...

Reply

Leave a reply

Replying to Amir Cancel

Then why give him any credit? He is a racist, misogynistic sociopath.

Comments are reviewed before they appear.