Wednesday, 15th July 2026 Cardiff 18° · Overcast
NationCymru A news service by the people of Wales, for the people of Wales.

Opinion

Regime Change for the USA

By Mark Mansfield
US President Donald Trump during the G7 summit in Kananaskis, Alberta, Canada. Photo Suzanne Plunkett/PA Wire

Ben Wildsmith

In the bizarre paradigm that Donald Trump has forced upon the world, his reliable advantage has been the loyalty that other leaders have to conventions that seemingly no longer serve a purpose.

With each new outrage against accepted practice, Trump has ploughed through the diplomatic handwringing of his supposed allies and brushed aside objections without reference to any pretence of morality. He can do it, so he’s doing it, end of discussion.

For Europeans, this has been a traumatic change of style, and since Greenland came into play, substance too. Common purpose with the USA has been the foundation of European statecraft since World War II.

In return for protection, Europe has been content to remain largely passive on the world stage, lending a hand when asked, and deferring to the USA as its senior partner.

When the pendulum of American politics swung only so far, it was predictable enough as a partner for European nations not to question this relationship.

Whilst America could become more bellicose under presidents such as Reagan or either Bush, the nation’s attitude towards Europe, and by extension the UK, was a largely settled component of foreign policy that continued regardless of political change.

Understandably, we now look at that cosy arrangement wistfully. It seems that in the blink of an eye we have been yanked from geopolitical comfort and plunged into a new world of danger and uncertainty. Can’t we have that nice Mr Obama back?

The reality is that Trump, who may well not understand diplomatic precedent, and is certainly unconcerned about breaking it, has awoken Europe from an unethical and hypocritical slumber.

Because, even under its most progressive leaders, the USA has pursued a larcenous foreign policy with our tacit approval. What’s happening to Denmark now will come as no surprise to anybody in the Middle East or South America, where failure to play ball with US corporations has routinely coincided with presidential helicopter crashes and military coups d’etats.

Throughout decades of this Europe has done virtually nothing to curb American excesses on the world stage, accepting free military protection and playing along with the fiction that we share a uniquely virtuous approach to human rights. Meanwhile, overseas deaths resulting from American military actions since WWII stand between 8-11 million.

So, take away the privilege of free protection from other supposed threats and how do we feel, as Europeans, about our relationship with the USA? Could it be that the sneering contempt of Donald J Trump is a truer representation of our ally than the polished routines of Obama, Clinton, Kennedy and the rest?

Standard American practice

Nothing Trump is doing differs from standard American practice around the world, what’s changed is that he feels no need to fabricate justifications for it and he’s happy to include Europe as a target.

The rest of the world has every right to raise an eyebrow at European horror over Greenland and wonder why we are so surprised.

So, what to do? Well, there’s no appeasing it, that’s for sure. Everything that has been laid at the door of Putin’s Russia applies to Trump’s America.

The mere suggestion of annexing Greenland renders NATO a defunct organisation upon which nobody in Europe can rely.

It is time to stop hoping that America will return to its previous incarnation and engage with the reality of what it has become. A hollowed-out alliance with this unpredictable, violent, and acquisitive entity is not in Europe’s interests.

It is time to signal that new relationships with Russia and China will be on the table unless the USA ends all talk of taking European land. It is time to speak over the heads of the Trump administration and address Americans directly.

If they value their relationship with Europe, they should be effecting regime change at the earliest opportunity. If not, they are on their own.


Support our Nation today

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

17 comments

Amir

At least our UK government does speak up on the cost of living crisis and our beloved NHS. Trump can't even admit that the US has a cost of living crisis. He has broken most of his electoral promises especially with sharing out the money accumulated from the tariffs to the US citizens. And stopping all America's wars. Venezuela, Iran, Nigeria, Greenland and Europe....

Reply
hdavies15

"At least our UK government does speak up on the cost of living crisis and our beloved NHS"..... Speak up? What use is that? UK Gov are drivers of the cost of living crisis in collusion with big business. We get loads of empty rhetoric about hard working people and other cliches but they have steadfastly refused to get off the pot where radical change is needed just relying on the scatter gun approach to taxation and spending that has failed for decades.

Reply
Amir

The government is distracted by the boats rubbish that Garage and his band of clowns spout out every 2 minutes. When that gets slightly addressed with one in, one out, these clowns move on the grooming gangs painting all people of south Asian descent as paedophiles. And then the government addresses that with a limited inquiry which seems to only worsen those claims and ignores the recommendations of the Jay report. They there clowns move on to halaal meat availability everywhere with nothing else for children to eat. As stupid as that sounds, it gets amplified and blown out any reasonable person's imagination. All the while, no one can talk about the cost of living crisis and how to address it and remdy it.

Reply
Richard Jenkins

Ben on the money again! Too often we kowtow to the might of the US & its propaganda arm called Hollywood. Time for Cymru particularly to take a dignified stand.

Reply
coldcomfort

It won't come as a surprise to anyone outside Europe, and I expect many would just ask, justifiably, "So how do you like being the ones on the table being carved?". Much to agree with, though I don't see much hope of forging a beneficial relationship with Putin. Still, we can't wish him away and all wars except those of annihilation end in talk. We haven't got all the tools we would wish for and we'll just have to make best use of those we do have. Dropping delusions of "special relationships", of still being an independent Great Power and of unique virtue should have happened long ago. And we should have got to work making new realistic relationships and a new way of living in the world as it now is and as the UK now is. Though I can't think of any former Great Power that's managed to decline and find a new role without crisis and upheaval along the way. Hope we're at the point where the veil has dropped and the crisis is big enough. The only point of cheer I can see at the moment is that according to polls US voters definitely do not support Trump on Greenland, so speaking over Trump's head might start to get some sort of hearing (it wouldn't have throughout last year) and might help Congress and the Senate get a bit of backbone.

Reply
John Ellis

Theoretically quite a lot, under the US political system which was in fact designed to establish a separation of powers. It's just that under Trump 2.0 that isn't working. Partly because the Republicans control both houses of their 'congress', and, as in every democratic political culture, they hesitate to come out against a president who is one of their own. But chiefly for fear of alienating Trump's very personal voter base, lest Trump call on his fans in the electorate to punish them when they seek re-election.

Reply
Keith

Don't pretend the US fell into the role of World Police as an act of charity. War and the threat of war is a nice little earner for the US defense industry and after the Cold War they needed new ways to keep their government spending tax dollars with their industry. And they lobbied and funded politics to make sure that happened.

Reply
Anonymous

Well that game is largely over, the US taxpayer will not stand for it. Look at how the USA is now supplying weapons to the Ukraine only because Europe is paying for them - the US taxpayer is VERY reluctant to further fork out US tax dollars.  https://www.euractiv.com/news/europeans-ponying-up-to-fund-us-weapons-shipments-to-ukraine/

Reply
Larry

Wait til they're asked to pay for Greenland.

Reply
Mab Meirion

We know something about 'Special Relationships' here in Cymru...108 days Plaid...

Reply
Rob

Trump to the President of Norway quote: "Considering your Country decided not to give me the Nobel Peace Prize for having stopped 8 Wars PLUS, I no longer feel an obligation to think purely of Peace, although it will always be predominant, but can now think about what is good and proper' for the US" They need to invoke the 25th amendment ASAP. Mind you its not the first time I've said that. He should have been disqualified from standing for office after January 6th.

Reply
Mab Meirion

Perfume oligarch Lauder behind Twmp's planned invasion of Greenland...Guardian

Reply
Gary225

No true sentient being would have written what he did without realising how contemptuous that was. Only earned plaudits are worth a candle. Putin may be evil but he seems sane. Trump is increasingly unbalanced and unpredictable and he has his finger on a button that can destroy us all. We are at the mercy of rational Americans conspiring to get rid of the Trump band in any way that is legal. Meanwhile beware our own slide into Trumplike fascist fantasyland with Farage.

Reply
Anonymous

Who is "they"?

Reply
Frank

I wonder how Trump and the US would fare against a country with some muscle? Venezuela and Greenland are easy walk-over countries.

Reply
Anonymous

"Can’t we have that nice Mr Obama back?" President Obama also pleaded with Europe to 'step up to the plate' by coughing up more money on its own defense but was IGNORED.  

Reply
Larry

Luckily for Donny, typing in capital letters in no way makes the writer seem unhinged.

Reply

Leave a reply

Replying to Amir Cancel

The government is distracted by the boats rubbish that Garage and his band of clowns spout out every 2 minutes. When that gets slightly addressed with one in, one out, these clowns move on the grooming gangs painting all people of south As...

Comments are reviewed before they appear.