Sat, 18th July Cardiff 19°
Nation.Cymru wordmark
Advertisement

Opinion

How Starmer's cynicism is driving people to Reform

By Mark Mansfield
Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer gives a speech in Buckinghamshire setting out his Government's "plan for change". Photo Darren Staples/PA Wire

Martin Shipton

The victory of former army major Stuart Keyte - Reform UK’s first elected councillor in Wales - at a Torfaen by-election on Thursday may mark a watershed in Welsh politics.

He immediately issued a warning to Labour that none of its council seats in Wales are safe.

Cllr Keyte may have a point, although I’m old enough to remember when a man called David Shand became the SDP’s first ever elected councillor at a 1981 by-election in Sedgefield, Co Durham, where I was living at the time. Two years later Tony Blair became Sedgefield's Labour MP, and 14 years after that he began an eight-year stint as Prime Minister.

Meanwhile Mr Shand had come and gone, as indeed had the SDP. Reform may suffer the same fate, although I have a feeling that the populist right will be with us for some time.

[mid-content-banner]

Depressing

It happens that Thursday was also publication day for the book Get In: The Inside Story of Labour Under Starmer by the journalists Patrick Maguire and Gabriel Pogrund, which I’m finding an interesting but depressing read.

Its focus is the Labour Party and its bid under Starmer to dislodge the Conservatives from power after 14 years, although Nigel Farage and Reform are a vaguely looming presence.

The book’s focus is on the behind-the-scenes goings-on as Starmer’s chief strategist Morgan McSweeney - rather than Starmer himself - engineered the changes that resulted in Labour’s general election landslide in July 2024.

As with many books of this kind, there is a fair sprinkling of gossip amid the political analysis.

We learn, for example, how Swansea East MP Carolyn Harris, Starmer’s earliest fan in Wales, was sacked as his Parliamentary Private Secretary after spreading a rumour that Angela Rayner was having an adulterous relationship with another Shadow Cabinet minister.

More substantially, a major theme of the book is how McSweeney and his associates deliberately deceived ordinary members of the Labour Party into believing that Starmer would keep the radical policies they had found attractive about Jeremy Corbyn’s leadership.

The so-called Ten Pledges, released during the leadership campaign, included increasing income tax for the wealthiest 5%; returning rail, mail, energy and water to public ownership; abolishing student tuition fees and Universal Credit; and giving MPs a veto over overseas military interventions by British forces.

[lower-mid-content-banner]

U-turns

Later Starmer was criticised for the series of U-turns in which he dropped most of the pledges. They’ve been put forward as examples of his inconsistency, but the book tells us there was never any intention to pursue the left-wing policies: it was all just a ruse to get Starmer elected as leader - something he knew from the outset. Ironically, the Ten Pledges had considerable public support at the time, although to McSweeney they were anathema.

Having secured Starmer’s election, McSweeney embarked on destroying the left as a force within the party, using a variety of means to do so, including improving the organisation of right wing members as a faction and using procedural mechanisms.

A further significant revelation in the book is that Starmer was, in essence, a vehicle for McSweeney and others to mould into the kind of leader they were looking for. In other words, they weren’t following him because they agreed with his ideology. He was, to all intents and purposes, an empty vessel without baggage that they could manipulate.

The mould was created before he was fitted to it. The most passionate personality trait he possessed was his ambition, to appease which he was happy to be manipulated by his advisers.

Brexit

Underlying all of this was the assumption that the bulk of the British people - apart from a metropolitan elite - was instinctively right wing. As a result, a decision was made that it would be a mistake to reopen the issue of Brexit. Arguments about the way Brexit was damaging to the economy were “unhelpful” and might incline those who had voted Leave in the 2016 referendum on EU membership to continue feeling alienated from Labour.

McSweeney and Starmer got their way and the Labour left is now an impotent, spent force.

The lack of radicalism and perceived policy delivery has, however, now driven voters into the arms of a party that is even further to the right than the Tories.

Policies on Reform’s website seem either wildly optimistic in terms of how much revenue they will deliver for the UK Government or designed to give tax breaks skewed to the wealthy.

Equally, no consideration is given to the existence of devolution, and that the Welsh Government may wish to do things in a different way. Perhaps there’s already a built-in assumption that Reform will be in power at the Senedd by the time of the next scheduled general election in 2029, with its local cohort happy to take orders from “Nigel”.

We are heading in a dangerous direction. Before long we could find people in government who want to reintroduce the death penalty, implementation of which would make us one of only two nations in Europe - the other being Belarus - to engage in judicial execution.

As someone who knows people who have wrongly spent years in prison for murder, having been falsely convicted before ultimately being exonerated, I am shocked that this could be a possibility.

I also find it thoroughly shocking that a political party like Labour feels it necessary to pander to the basest instincts of voters to get elected.

Farage is, of course, well tuned-in to Trump’s America, where many people have no empathy with or sympathy for those who are less well off than they are, deriding the notion of a National Health Service as “socialist healthcare” - something which is intrinsically evil. As things stand, such a view is, I’m pleased to say, unlikely to gain currency here. If it’s ever seriously mooted, it could lead to Farage’s - and Reform’s - downfall.

Nevertheless, the book Get In shows how in the mindset of Starmer’s Labour, leadership is not about being honest with people about what is achievable and inspiring them to strive for the best, but settling cynically for what people will find superficially attractive while knowing it’s to their disadvantage - as in the attitude towards the EU.

This is not a way to run a country and achieve success. It increases disillusionment for ordinary people, thus making them even more susceptible to bad players who see them as a route to power.

Once installed they will dance to the tune of their billionaire masters.

What a sorry state we are in. We need a rescue strategy badly. Who will supply it?

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Get more trusted Welsh news

Choose Nation.Cymru as a preferred source in Google News to see more of our journalism.

Choose Nation.Cymru as a preferred source in Google News

42 comments

Mab Meirion

Another political broadcast on behalf of the one and only alternative party...

Reply
Mab Meirion

Morgan le Fey gender bent but Clark is under his spell...is MI5 still turned off in Downing St because there has been an awful lot of treason going on in our Governments for decades...

Reply
Hal

At the root of this mess is a voting system that has created two main "broad church" parties that are forever infighting with half always unhappy about the direction their party is heading, forced to choose between supporting their party or being honest. The duplicity this invariably creates is what undermines public trust in politicians. We need a voting system that supports smaller parties so the electorate, not party factions or membership cliques, get to decide how socialist or freemarketeerist the resulting coalition government is. Until then any attempt to drag Labour to the left will see them out of power and a real right wing government take back control. End the broad church nonsense and give voters a real choice at the ballot box.

Reply
Mab Meirion

Plan for Change...(Play for Change) No plan u plan a plan g plan What is this Cochin talking about, Is that right that he's an Anarchist, Bent on destroying this country inside out Giving the old place the kiss of death After fifteen years of Tory treason and theft... Guantanamo Bay one river down from Desolation Bay... When's Billy Graham playing the Trwmp Arena next... Preppers Paradise: Welcome to Paradise There is a coup coming on, Welcome to Paradise There is a coup coming on... Secularise it... Thanks 10cc Rev Millar wants to use Cymru and his place in it as a foothold, underwritten by Cymru's Tax payers, to the Great God Trwmp...Bin him...

Reply
Siadwell Edwards

The people of Wales have put their trust in Labour for a long time and been betrayed. Plaid cant get their head around the FACT that most Welsh, especially those in the densely populated south east of Wales and the Valleys, are very proud of being British, but, they still might vote for an independent Wales IF it wasn't driven by the Welsh language brigade who constantly use the language as a weapon against those who don.t speak it. Fact of the matter is that Welsh I dependence is a middle class movement, ironic, as many of them have gravy train jobs paid for by the English tax payer. As usual the establishment wins. First up against the wall

Reply
Y Cymro

A self hating post full of trigger words, inaccuracies, lined with pernicious populist rhetoric of the alt-right. Yes, by all means Siadwell attack 26 years of Welsh Labour rule, do, especially the recent UK Labour controversies and policy flip flopping, but don't you dare omit any damage done to Wales by the Conservatives or Nigel Farage with Brexit. Also, anyone who ridicules their own language whilst claiming English money effectively keeps Wales afloat should get their bloody facts right. We pay tax too. And don't forget, it's our water resource & Crown Estate that also makes billions for English water companies , the English Monarchy & Whitehall treasury, billions I might add that we in Wales don't receive one penny of. And how you can claim that Plaid Cymru betrays Wales is baffling when both the Conservatives & Labour in London have denied us £4 billion in HS2 consequential, money that's rightfully ours. No criticism of this by you I see? Just attacks on the Welsh language, devolution, and how British you feel. Oh, sorry. Doesn't fit your Anti-Welsh narrative does it? Thought as much. I noticed you highlighted in your rant how those in the South Wales valleys are proud of being British, would vote for independence if it was for those weaponizing the Welsh language. Oh but they voted for those, Ukip & Brexit party demonizing asylum seekers. You forget this fact. We Cymry , not Welsh, I am not a foreigner, are the true native British. And Cymraeg, not English , Britain's original native language. Sorry to burst your little BritNat bubble. I deal with facts , not alternative facts favoured by pork rind populists. And those same valleys that are so proud to be British are so dirt poor they qualified three times for EU Structural Funding due to decades of neglect & underinvestment by Westminster. And to rub salt into their open wound. You and your ilk by voting for Brexit has made them even poorer. Now who betraying who? And less we forget. Only the other day both Labour & Conservatives defeated Plaid Cymru's motion at Westminster to devolve the Crown Estate to Wales. So as I said, it's laughable when you make such vacuous accusations of betrayal towards Plaid Cymru when it's only they who are fighting our corner not only on Wales but at Westminster where you opt to knife Wales in the back. Truth hurts. Own it.

Reply
Undecided

I think you also have to own the truth that Mr Edwards and his “ilk” represented the majority of Welsh voters on Brexit. I was on the losing side btw.

Reply
Sian Davies

Cymraeg is not the original language of Britain, it was Celtic which then became: Breton, Manx, Cymraeg, Cornish and Gaelic.

Reply

In reply to Sian Davies

Drew Anderson

The people that hoofed it across the land bridges 10,000, or more, years ago did not speak Celtic languages. Proto Indo-European languages, of which the Celtic languages are derivations, didn't even arrive in Europe until 5,000 years ago.

Reply

In reply to Sian Davies

Y Cymro

Yes, there are indeed other languages spoken in Britain other than Cymraeg, one is a daughter language of Cymraeg being Kernewek (Cornish) and the other an offshoot of Irish being Scots Gaelic. And Cornish (Kernewek) today sound different to Cymraeg because it's a language revived and largely influenced by English hence why there's no Ll or Ch sounds in Cornish. And in Wales we have manuscripts predating Cornish at the National Library of Waled, Aberystwyth. One in particular written in Old Welsh thought from Wales was likely done by a scribe from Cornwall. And the other Celtic language (Scottish Gaelic) spoken in Britain was itself taken to what now is Scotland by the Irish Scotti tribe replacing the original Welsh speaking tribes of Hen Ogledd. Also the dead language referred to as Pictish , spoken by the Picts (Latin meaning painted) , were not one people but a collection of Brythoneg speaking tribes from Hen Ogledd (Old North ) who evaded Roman rule. The debate Pictish is a separate language is disputed seeing no speakers are alive and the place names are effectively Welsh i.e Glasgow, Aberdeen, Trossachs, Aberfeldy, Caledonia etc... And recently DNA were taken of Pictish skeletons and they were indistinguishable from other native British tribes. And the Isle of Man's language (Manx) is an offshoot of Gaelach (Irish) with influences of Norse with it being a Viking settlement in the past with its Tynwald the oldest continuous Parliament in the world. And itself technically isn't part of Britain being autonomous, although the United Kingdom is responsible for its defence. And less we forget. The term Brythonic itself was coined by Celticist & scholar John Rees in reference to his own language i.e Cymraeg. And similarly with Gaelach (Irish) as Manx, Scottish Gaelic diverged from its Irish mother tongue, Germanic Saxon did with its daughter language English as American will eventually from English and be classified as a separate language.

Reply
Tracy

I think the man doth protest to much!

Reply
Fanny Hill

Remember that John Sparks character, Siadwell, from a few years ago, Enough said.

Reply
Alan Jones

What utter utter drivel.

Reply
Eric Blair

Siadwell you have to understand that Nation Cymru censors replies, it has an agenda and is totally and completely censorious in what posts and answers it allows, It does not allow polite discussion if the person posting has valid points that go against its agenda.

Reply
Adrian

What escapes Labour is that everyone is fully aware that Starmer doesn’t actually believe in anything. They were only elected, by default, because they Tories were so dire. People seemed to be thinking ‘how could it be worse?’: well now they know.

Reply
Hal

Why does every PM have to "believe". What's this pitiful need for dogma really about. Haven't we had enough of cult leaders like Thatcher, Blair and Johnson?

Reply
Adrian

You've missed the point: Starmer is a vacuous weather-vane who's interested only in his own advancement. I expect a British PM to believe in Britain and Starmer clearly does not. I accept, though, that you may have lower expectations of those you vote for,

Reply

In reply to Adrian

Hal

You can't even get the basics right. "Britain" doesn't exist. The name of the state is the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, usually abbreviated to "UK". "Britain" might one day be an acceptable shorthand for the state when Northern Ireland leaves the union, and the state is renamed Great Britain after the island it encompasses. Until then repeated use of "Britain" referring to the big island that excludes Northern Ireland simply pushes them towards the exit.

Reply

In reply to Hal

Adrian

Ah - ‘Britain doesn’t exist’…got it! 😂

Reply

In reply to Adrian

Hal

Not in the real world. It may feature in the imagination of the deluded. The sort that think Brexit is possible despite Thatcher closing all the exportable wealth creating industries and hooking the UK onto Europe. The sort that think "Making Britian Great Again" is possible without a network of colonies where people are forced to work for free.

Reply

In reply to Hal

Fanny Hill

I don't know why you bother, Adrian's good for a laugh and a wind up but much point trying to reason with him, bless him.

Reply

In reply to Adrian

Fanny Hill

“You’ve missed the point: Starmer is a vacuous weather-vane who’s interested only in his own advancement” You meant Farage surely?

Reply

In reply to Adrian

Jeff

Nige, we don't like billionaire's meddling in UK politics. Musk. Here is a ton of loot. Nige. Loverly. Don't mind if I do. Nige. Brexit eh, what a deal. I will leave the UK if t fails. UK. Brexit now failed. you said... Nige.....er shouty shouty nasty reporter go away....

Reply
Fanny Hill

And Farage.

Reply
Fanny Hill

You think this is worse? If have your way you’d have Putin’s other mate, Farage, in No. 10. God help us then.

Reply
Charles Coombes

Living in Dolgellau I see the only way I can vote is Plaid. We have an excellent MP and the Party is more socialist than Labour has been for 20 years.

Reply
Mab Meirion

The lawyer is an Ass...isn't that right Mr and Mrs Bumble...

Reply
Mab Meirion

The breakaway State of Gwynedd Mon has gone from strength to strength since cutting off the dead weight of the South East...

Reply
Mab Meirion

Not so says Gwynedd Control Tower, we are in auto-rotation and passengers should prepare for our pockets to be picked on landing...

Reply
Paul

So there’s not much difference between this Labour and Reform. Both parties are offering what they think people want but have no intention of carrying out their promises. Wouldn’t it be nice if someone formed ‘The Honesty Party’ ?

Reply
Barnaby

People don't want honesty. Imagine how a party that said "you made a terrible choice with Brexit, now we're going to have to make you even poorer to pay for it and increase immigration to have enough workers to fund the exploding population of retirees" would do at the ballot box.

Reply
John

Personally I would say misleading the labour party to ensure that a non-corbynite became labour leader was not such a bad thing. In our corner of Wales, momentum activists alienated older party members who had been there for 20 odd years. Very argumentive and unwilling to find a middle ground. Cleaning up the labour party post Corbyn has been one of starmer's achievements. After all corbyn was one of the reasons the UK got a hard brexit. After that, the party really been gutted of talented politicians from 2015 onwards and ideally needed another election cycle to formulate workable policies On Brexit, as someone who lives in the EU, I can't see anything beyond some minor technical changes for the foreseeable future. Sorry but labour are being realistic on this

Reply
Linda Jones

Good article, spot on. Starmer and co have taken the Labour party so far to the right they are indistinguishable from the tories. In so doing he has robbed ordinary people of any mainstream political choices. Farage is filling that void.

Reply
Dewi

Keir Starmer—like all barristers—is a deeply cynical man. You would be too if you’d spent decades wading through the legal system, witnessing first-hand its many absurdities. Labour, desperate to get elected, decided the best way forward was to abandon its principles entirely. Their strategy? Offend no one, inspire even fewer, and rely on the sheer incompetence of the Tories to drift into power unchallenged. And it worked! The problem now is that we have a government as hollow as a cheap chocolate Easter egg, forced to raid pensioners’ heating allowances because they foolishly assumed no Labour government would ever stoop so low—so they never bothered to promise not to. If it weren’t for Mossad and the useful idiots in Welsh Labour, Jeremy Corbyn would have won on a much stronger platform. If you doubt it, watch The Labour Files and ask yourself: who really put up Owen Smith as a decoy? And, more importantly, why did he then quit politics to flog Viagra to Australians with brewer’s droop? Meanwhile, Carwyn Jones was busy grandstanding, insisting that Welsh Labour’s pro-business stance was why it succeeded where Corbyn failed. But the reality is, Labour remains in a death grip—not just from corporate interests but from the same foreign influence that turned the anti-Semitism row into a farcical inquisition. Corbyn was expelled for having met Hamas decades ago, while Margaret Hodge can cheer on Israel’s latest bloodbath without consequence. Now, progressives find themselves up a creek without a paddle, and the first thing in the reactionary right’s crosshairs is our beloved Senedd. It could be fatal. The difference between 1979 and 1997? Thatcherism, and more specifically, privatisation. Back then, Wales was an industrial powerhouse under state ownership—British Leyland, the NCB, British Steel, British Rail. Workers, knowing they’d never had it so good, had no desire to sever the umbilical cord linking them, their unions, and the government. Then came the Milk Snatcher, who tore it all down. The Welsh flirted with nationalism, but now history repeats itself. Over the horizon, here comes Nigel Farage, wielding Trump’s playbook of reindustrialisation, tariffs, and zero immigration. The Welsh will flock to it—not because of some reawakened nationalist spirit, but because they still remember the days when open-cast miners were raking in huge salaries, living in cheap council houses complete with cocktail cabinets, a Ford Granada in the driveway, and two weeks in Benidorm. Since then, it’s been downhill all the way. If only they could go back to not thinking and just extracting coal. PNEUMATIC DRILL, BOYO, PNEUMATIC DRILL. Arthur Scargill, now 86, may yet live to see the pits reopened—not by the left, but by the right, which has finally realised that free markets were a disaster. And where is the left in Wales? Nowhere. Not a word of opposition to this doctrine. Just look at what JD Vance, the US Vice President, said in Munich. The world’s largest economy has abandoned net-zero policies entirely, so why on earth is Wales tying itself in knots over a bypass in Llandeilo? Hot air, indeed. Either the effort was collective, or it was doomed from the start. Reform UK could kill devolution stone dead. But would it really matter? The Welsh never got used to governing themselves anyway—they’ve been dependent on England for too long. Meanwhile, Irish reunification marches forward, with Brexit having economically unified the island already (what exactly was the DUP thinking when they backed Brexit?). Scotland won’t be fooled by Farage’s nonsense, and the SNP will likely be re-elected, still dreaming of shipbuilding in Govan. Under Alex Salmond, they were ahead of their time in climate scepticism—he was never going to let the “It’s Scotland’s Oil” argument be surrendered to the eco-loons. I’d like to say, “It was good while it lasted in Wales.” But let’s not kid ourselves—we all know it never really was.

Reply
Adrian

Labour has somehow managed to alienate the majority of the country within the the first 6 months.. Cutting winter fuel payments. Waging war against farmers. Crippling small businesses by raising taxes in the budget in the wrong manner just to say they haven't U turned on their manifesto. Plus labelling the majority of their red wall far right for being concerned about immigration and terrorism. That's before you take in consideration the performance of the clowns down the Bay.

Reply
Jeff

How much damage did brexit do. How much damage has it yet to complete. Your hero, St Nige of pocketing loot form nazi saluters will wreck the joint. You dont have any metrics to say that the benefits for brexit have outweighed staying in the EU. If you want to see what happens when idiots take charge, look to the US now, in real time, it is getting gutted by the same nazi saluting billionaire that fagage is lusting after.

Reply
Mab Meirion

There is a man from Cork steering 'SS UK Titanic II' with Clark along for the ride...

Reply
John

Sadly I think this will be remembered as the parliament where Brexit actually got done, and the principle impacts were felt. UK hasn’t implemented full border checks yet

Reply
Mark

Might I politely point out that Adrian didn't mention Brexit or anybody by the name of St Nige? He simply listed a few straightforward facts.

Reply

In reply to Mark

Fanny Hill

To be fair to Jeff and other fans of Adrian on here, you do realise we can read Adrian's mind when he takes his tin foil hat off.

Reply
Matthew

The only thing driving people to Reform is the fact that they are absolute chancers who simply pretend to care about working people. Remember all the promises we had from the Leave campaign that many of the Reform lot were from about how it would make life better and how much actually came true? The only thing they cared about was getting out of the EU quickly before the UK was subject to EU tax avoidance directives that would have cost a lot of rich people a lot of money. The rest was all bait and switch stuff that conmen use all the time. The sad thing is people are still falling for it. As bad as this Government are, or the previous one was, any Government with Reform in it will be many orders worse.

Reply
Maesglas

We need a rescue strategy, who will supply it says Martin. Definitely not Starmer' Labour, a party that will get swept along by any tide - including Farage and Trump. Starmer's soulless politics will destroy Labour and Wales.

Reply

Leave a reply

Replying to Adrian Cancel

You've missed the point: Starmer is a vacuous weather-vane who's interested only in his own advancement. I expect a British PM to believe in Britain and Starmer clearly does not. I accept, though, that you may have lower expectations of tho...

Comments are reviewed before they appear.