Sun, 9th August Cardiff 23°
Nation.Cymru wordmark
Advertisement

News

Work from home parents blamed for poor attendance at Welsh schools

By Emily Price
Working from home

Twm Owen - Local democracy reporter

Parents who work from home have been blamed for continued poor attendance at Welsh schools. 

A top councillor in Monmouthshire previously responsible for education said parents who work from home for part of the week have been telling schools they see no reason why their children shouldn’t be able to do the same. 

The Welsh Government issued new guidance on school attendance two years ago amid concerns it hadn’t recovered following the 2020 Covid lockdowns that saw school closures extended into 2021.

It also changed its definition of “persistent absence” from a child missing more than 20 per cent of half day school sessions, or 10 full school days, to the figure used in England of 10 per cent or just five school days. 

[mid-content-banner]

Lockdowns

Councillor Martyn Groucutt, who previously had responsibility for education in Monmouthshire, said school attendance hasn’t recovered since the pandemic when lockdown meant most pupils were told to stay at home and follow online learning. 

Speaking at a county council scrutiny meeting, discussing a well-being plan, Cllr Groucutt said: “There is an elephant in the room.  Since the pandemic too many families have stopped sending their children to school regularly.” 

He added: “Attendance has still not caught up to attendance we were used to over time. Parents are contacting schools and saying ‘I work from home three days a week, why can’t my children do the same?’ It doesn’t work like that.” 

The retired former headteacher and education officer said friends of his have home educated their children, which he described as “very far from easy thing to do” but said attending school is the most suitable form of education for the majority of children. 

He said: “I’m not saying home education should never happen but the vast, vast majority of children need to be with their friends, peers and community learning.”

[lower-mid-content-banner]

Report

The Abergavenny Labour councillor, who stepped down as Monmouthshire County Council’s cabinet member for education in May, said he’d last week become chair of governors at Cross Ash Primary School and reported attendance for youngsters in the reception class for the first month of the new term that started in September was “about 98 per cent”. 

He said: “I just hope they realise it’s not just a month it goes on until they are 18-years-old.” 

Compulsory schooling in Wales ends at 16 years of age. 

The annual report from Monmouthshire County Council’s director of education, for 2024/25, stated “overall attendance of pupils in Monmouthshire schools, post-pandemic, has improved” with primary school attendance “moving rapidly towards pre-pandemic levels” but described attendance in secondary schools as “slower to recover”. 

Figures show overall attendance in Monmouthshire increased to 90 per cent in 2023/24 which was one per cent higher than the all-Wales figure though both had improved by 0.5 per cent on the previous year. 

Attendance for Monmouthshire primary pupils was 93.60 per cent, compared to 92.20 per cent across Wales, while attendance for secondary school pupils was 88.20 per cent and the all-Wales figure 88.10 per cent. 

The Welsh Government has said “good attendance” is usually at around 95 per cent. 

It has said the percentage of secondary school-aged pupils missing more than 10 per cent of sessions, five whole days, fell from 37.1 per cent to 33.0 per cent between 2023/24 and 2024/25. 

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Get more trusted Welsh news

Choose Nation.Cymru as a preferred source in Google News to see more of our journalism.

Choose Nation.Cymru as a preferred source in Google News

5 comments

Evan Aled Bayton

Home education should be stopped except in very rare circumstances. All kids who are home educated should be listed at a school and regularly assessed for progress. Home education is a risk factor for child neglect and child abuse. Part of education is meeting other people and learning about society.

Reply
smae

I think it's time the education sector caught up with the times. All they need to do is wear a microphone and set up a camera and the student could literally be observing from anywhere for at least part of the week. Not all classes involve group work, a good many are basically a short lecture, followed by a period of self study, followed by a knowledge check. In such classes, there's really no need to actually be in the room at all with modern tech. This could also free up teachers from having to commute every day and reduce the need for classrooms. Students would be able to record their lectures and provide feedback in real time that would be also recorded if not written. Further, you're much more likely to see engagement from introvert students. There's nothing worse than sticking your hand up, getting the answer wrong and being laughed at and it really puts students off from engaging, kids are kids and learning respect comes with practice. Further, despite teachers being somewhat unwilling to engage with technology on the whole, the classroom can be a distracting place when students prefer to chat rather than do their work. At home they might have the support of their parents and they won't have the additional distraction from fellow chatty students allowing them to get on and do what they need to do. Also, since they don't have to commute themselves, learning time could be increased. Not all students will be able to avail themselves of this opportunity though, so while fewer classrooms might be needed and fewer days in school for the teachers and students there will of course be some time where students come in. Home schooling has serious advantages and should not be sniffed at. If a teacher finds that homework isn't been completed, or that they are not paying attention, then they have disciplinary tools available, if disciplinary tools fail to work, the child on a case by case basis can have their home working privilege revoked.

Reply
Jeff

Nothing wrong with work from home. That is not the real reason.

Reply
Howie

WFH is promoted by the Welsh Govt, a chunk of Senedd members still do it. Are they saying they got it wrong?

Reply
Unice Thornberry

No they have never got anything wrong.

Reply

Leave a reply

Replying to Jeff Cancel

Nothing wrong with work from home. That is not the real reason.

Comments are reviewed before they appear.