Fri, 21st August Cardiff 13°
Nation.Cymru wordmark
Advertisement

News

Opposition parties criticise final budget ahead of Senedd vote

By Mark Mansfield
Finance Secretary Mark Drakeford

Both main opposition parties in The Senedd have criticised the Welsh Government’s final budget for the next financial year, which will be voted on later today (Tuesday 4 March).

Plaid Cymru and the Welsh Conservatives have said they will vote against the budget, which was published on 20 February, after the government agreed a deal with Liberal Democrat only MS, Jane Dodds, given them enough votes for the budget proposals to go through.

Plaid Cymru’s finance spokesperson Heledd Fychan said that despite repeated promises of change, Wales remains short-changed under Labour – from the £4bn HS2 funding denied by Westminster to Labour’s refusal to grant Wales control over its own natural resources.

Ms Fychan said that the Welsh government budget could have been an opportunity to correct decades of unfairness and to show “real ambition” for Wales but instead continued a pattern of underinvestment in struggling Welsh public services like the NHS and local councils.

[mid-content-banner]

'Unfairness'

Speaking ahead of the final vote, Heledd Fychan said: “Wales was promised change under two Labour governments, but all we’ve had is more of the same – unfairness and a lack of ambition for our nation.

“We’re still denied the £4bn owed to us from HS2. There’s no fair funding deal to help our struggling public services. And just last week, Labour voted against Wales having control over our own natural resources – turning down millions in potential profit for our country.

“Plaid Cymru will always work with others where we can for the good of our nation. This budget, however, fails to meet the challenges facing Wales, from local government to our NHS and we therefore cannot support it.

“Wales needs fresh thinking and a government that won’t rest until our country gets fair play from Westminster. Plaid Cymru is the only party fighting for fairness for Wales – with ambitious, long-term solutions to improve our NHS, grow our economy, and build a stronger future for our nation.”

[lower-mid-content-banner]

'Woeful outcomes'

Welsh Conservative Shadow Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Sam Rowlands MS said: “Labour’s budget will not fix Wales, it will not address the people’s priorities, with woeful outcomes like excessive waiting lists and low educational standards speaking for themselves.

“Whether it’s Plaid, or now the Lib Dems propping Labour up, it is clear that only the Welsh Conservatives have consistently opposed Labour’s damaging spending plans, and focused on the people’s priorities.

“Welsh Conservatives would instead focus on putting money back into Welsh people’s pockets, starting with creating a Welsh Winter Fuel Allowance to replace the payment cut by Keir Starmer, funded by slashing inflated spending on Welsh Government bureaucrats.

“Labour’s woeful budget must be voted down, with Labour turfed out of office as soon as possible.”

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Get more trusted Welsh news

Choose Nation.Cymru as a preferred source in Google News to see more of our journalism.

Choose Nation.Cymru as a preferred source in Google News

5 comments

Llyn

So Plaid are not voting for the budget on principle because the HS2 money and control of the Crown Estate has not moved to Wales. So if they form the next Welsh Government they would I can only assume, guided by principle, vote against their own budget if the HS2 money and control of the Crown Estate had not moved to Wales.

Reply
Ernie The Smallholder

It proves that if a politician really wants the best for Wales then we must collect our own taxation and control our own economic policy. We are controlled and chained to an another country which does not share our same values and this will not change until Labour, Conservative and Reform UK, which are all centrally controlled from within the UK system are removed from Cymru Wales and we have our own based political system. The solution is not easy as we have seen from other peoples who struggles to break free of colonialism. Recently, we see the struggles from independence from Ireland, Cuba, Vietnam, now independent and now Ukraine, struggling for its very existence as an independent nation. It is now Wales and Scotland right to be a free and to be independent countries in Europe. Perhaps, also good for an independent England, all with modern liberal democratic political systems. As small nations, we need trading alliances and guarantees. There are many small countries like our own in the rest of Europe and there is the solution in progress: The European Union - The natural confederation of free independent nations of Europe.

Reply
Simon Hobson

Agreed! This budget debate emphasises not only the dire need for Cymru to place the future of our nation back into the hands of its citizens, it also highlights the poor quality of Wales politicians. Where is the vision? Where is the narrative to lead Cymru towards standing on its own two feet? Where is the ambition, bravery and creativity? There are so many of us in the Welsh diaspora who, despite, when we approach them, the spuringing of Senedd government and civil servants, continue to offer our global connections, experiences. money and energy to the betterment of Wales. We need our fellow Welsh citizens to support our endeavours, believe in themselves and back our nation. Cymru and its people do have so much to offer the world. We have to stop acting the victim and start pushing back, not just at Westminster, but also those among our own who would talk down Wales and its potential.

Reply
Mab Meirion

Lets hope the Senedd front row sees some serious changes in next year's transfer window... Their presence is constant reminder of recent bad times with little improvement in the present and the future looks a challenge that none of the old order are fit to face...

Reply
Dr John Ball

I really do feel that Heledd Fychan should take up comedy. Apparently, Plaid Cymru (has) "ambitious, long-term solutions to improve our NHS, grow our economy, and build a stronger future for our nation.” Er...where can the people of Wales see such wonders? I suppose such an imaginative contribution does raise a smile of disbelief. Far too busy bleating about HS2 and Crown Estate.

Reply

Leave a reply

Replying to Llyn Cancel

So Plaid are not voting for the budget on principle because the HS2 money and control of the Crown Estate has not moved to Wales. So if they form the next Welsh Government they would I can only assume, guided by principle, vote against thei...

Comments are reviewed before they appear.