Tue, 28th July Cardiff 19°
Nation.Cymru wordmark
Advertisement

News

'His name isn't Merlin': Social media creator hits back at mythical misconceptions

By Molly Stubbs
The Enchanter Merlin by Howard Pyle (Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=18494745)

A social media creator has hit back against misconceptions about the origins of Merlin, commonly believed to be a mythical wizard from the legend of King Arthur.

"His name isn't Merlin, it's Myrddin," writes Victoria Folkheart, a Welsh mystic and content creator, in her Instagram post. "And he wasn't a wizard either."

Over 9,000 people have liked the post, uploaded in mid-January, with 750 commenters largely in agreement.

Explaining how the mistranslation came about, Victoria wrote: "The name itself is an intentional mistranslation. Geoffrey of Monmouth changed it in the 12th century because the Latinised Welsh name 'Merdyn' looked too much like the French word 'Merde' (Sh*t) to his Norman patrons.

"He swapped the 'd' for an 'l' and Merlin was born."

A Catholic cleric, Geoffrey of Monmouth took from various historical accounts to present 'Merlin' in the form we know him today -- a mad magician and mentor figure to young Arthur.

By combining traditional Welsh stories of Myrddin and another prophet, Ambrosius, he created the composite character Merlinus Ambrosius. Though neither figure had any apparent connection to Arthur, the 'Merlin' character was popular in literature and in Wales.

This was further shaped by French writers, such as the poet Robert de Boron, who added to the legend of the wizard, claiming he was imprisoned by the Lady of the Lake after a one-sided romance.

But Victoria also disputes this, writing that in the original Welsh tales: "Myrddin wasn't a wizard. He was a poet and prophet deeply connected to the natural world - speaking to trees, living amongst wild creatures, channelling visions of what was to come...

"Geoffrey of Monmouth took these Welsh stories, combined them with tales of Ambrosius, relocated the timeline to Arthur's era, added magical elements, and created the wizard we recognise today.

"But strip away the medieval romance, the Norman embellishments, the Arthurian overlay - and you find the original figure:

"A Welsh bard. A prophet of his people. A man driven mad by war who found wisdom in wildness. A voice crying out from the forest, foretelling the fate of Britain.

"That's who Myrddin really was."

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Victoria FolkHeart Welsh Mystic | Celtic Spirituality & Witches (@victoriafolkheart)

Myrddin, in his later form as Merlin, has continued to play a prominent role in popular culture, most notably featured in the Disney movie The Sword in the Stone, which draws from Arthurian legend.

He was also portrayed by Colin Morgan in the eponymous BBC series, which was largely filmed in Wales, as well as England and France.

Geoffrey of Monmouth is also largely credited with the legend of Arthur, who is thought to be based on the Welsh kings Owain Ddantgwyn, Enniaun Girt and Athrwys ap Meurig.

Many commenters agreed with Victoria's post, thanking her for bringing the legend's true origins to light.

"Many a name has he and many a corruption placed upon the truth of it... one day we shall all see the truth of Myrddin," a commenter wrote, while another put it more simply: "Arthurian legend doing cultural appropriation."

"It begs the question: why couldn't Geoffrey of Monmouth just transcribe it as Merthin?" Another commenter wondered.

However, not everyone was convinced, with a user adding: "Funny how you're trying to claim him as Welsh. Back then there were no Welsh people or a Welsh nation."

Victoria frequently posts breakdowns of Welsh mythical figures on her Instagram, and offers Welsh lessons in a sound-healing setting. You can follow her here.

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Get more trusted Welsh news

Choose Nation.Cymru as a preferred source in Google News to see more of our journalism.

Choose Nation.Cymru as a preferred source in Google News

1 comment

Y Cymro

As one who takes interest in Welsh mythology know the story of Merlin, whose real was name Myrddin, and how the name was altered for obvious reasons by Geoffrey of Monmouth who audience spoke French The same can be said of numerous Welsh character that appear in Welsh mythology used in the Arthurian legend. Take Guinevere, itself a corruption of the middle Welsh Gwenhwyfar, changed from the earlier Old Welsh form, Guinhuimar. It's good that this author is sparking debate and educating those about Welsh mythology. Normally the original Welsh source is lost. And yes, English & French writers added to the tale, but people still think it's English legend when it most certainly is not. All the original source material is Welsh. Taken from not only the Mabinogi but from other books & manuscripts such as the Red Book of Hergest, White Book of Rhydderch, Black Book of Caerfyrddin and the Book of Taliesin. Not forgetting Welsh monk Nennius who first mentioned Arthur in Historia Brittonum circa 928AD. Also, in those manuscripts did it ever never mentioned Arthur was a king, born in Cornwall, or that he was English. After all, he fought against the Saxons, a German tribe ,who would later be part of the formation of England. So how could he be English? See, Cornish at the time circa 1130AD was still effectively Welsh until the influence of Norman French and English changed it removing the Welsh Ll, Dd, Ch, FF from the language , so branching it off from its mother tongue. Note: Cornwall was once referred to as South Wales. Similar occurred in the Old North, ( Hen Ogledd) with Rhedeg (Cumbria) & Deira (Northumberland & East Yorkshire) and other Welsh Kingdoms of Allt Clut , Din Eidin & Y Gododdin usurped by the Irish Scotti tribe to found was is now modern Scotland. He, Geoffrey of Monmouth , was also appealing to a Norman French court , who by this time were attacking Wales. So why place him here where the legend was born and written. Think about it They English obviously aware of Cornwall hence it's name. Two words. Corn = Welsh for Horn or Peninsular. And Wall, Germanic Saxon for Welshman = Stranger or Slave. So setting it Cornwall with its scenery made sense having a once cultural and linguistic connection. Sadly by this time Cornwall was incorporated into the Kingdom of England and in 1067 , and later in 1283 the Kingdoms of Wales would face a similar fate with the infamous Iron Ring under Edward "The Hammer" 1st Anyway, less we forget. How could Arthur be the King of England being a 5th century warrior fighting the Germanic Saxons, a tribe who would later unite with the Angles , Jutes & Frisians to found the Kingdom of England in 927AD under King Athelstan, some 427 odd years after he fought his documented battles. See, the England & English never existed during Arthur & Myrddin's time. Fact!

Reply

Leave a reply

Replying to Y Cymro Cancel

As one who takes interest in Welsh mythology know the story of Merlin, whose real was name Myrddin, and how the name was altered for obvious reasons by Geoffrey of Monmouth who audience spoke French The same can be said of numerous Welsh...

Comments are reviewed before they appear.