Wed, 19th August Cardiff 19°
Nation.Cymru wordmark
Advertisement

News

Cardiff council accused of 'imploring all city's residents to be Christians' in lamp post advert

By Mark Mansfield
One of the Easter posters in Cardiff

Martin Shipton

Humanists UK has criticised Cardiff council for displaying banners across the city in the run-up to Easter which feature text saying: “Trust in Jesus, He is Alive, Come to Church!’”and then feature its logo at the bottom.

The body says that while this is almost certainly paid advertising from an external organisation, this is not stated and so the impression given is very much that the council itself is imploring all its residents to be Christian.

[mid-content-banner]

Complaints

Over the last week since the banners seemingly first appeared, Wales Humanists has received multiple complaints about them.

Wales Humanists coordinator Kathy Riddick said: “Cardiff council serves a diverse community with a wide range of beliefs. It has a responsibility to remain impartial and not give the impression of favouring or endorsing any particular religion or belief. By failing to make sure these banners clearly state they are paid advertisements from an external group, the council is using its authority and branding to promote one specific faith.

“We call on Cardiff council to address the issue with urgency and then review its policies on lamp post banner advertising. Either it should make sure that all future adverts include prominent disclaimers regarding their origin, preventing any confusion with official council communications, or it should remove its own logo from the banners.”

[lower-mid-content-banner]

Advertising policy

A spokesperson for Cardiff council responded, stating: “Under the terms of Cardiff council’s advertising policy, registered charities and businesses are permitted to purchase banner space on council-owned lamp posts. The booking of this advertising space is managed by Bay Media, an external national provider of advertising space, in compliance with the council’s advertising policy.

“The Cardiff council logo is placed at the bottom of all banner advertising coordinated by Bay Media in the city to demonstrate that the advert has permission to be on council property. It does not indicate any formal partnership or endorsement of the specific content of the advertisements.

“The booking of advertising space is an external process, and beyond setting the parameters of the overarching advertising policy, the council does not take decisions regarding individual campaigns where they are compliant with the standards articulated in the policy.”

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Get more trusted Welsh news

Choose Nation.Cymru as a preferred source in Google News to see more of our journalism.

Choose Nation.Cymru as a preferred source in Google News

36 comments

Jeff

Other gods are available. When are they getting the same treatment same access.

Reply
Erisian

Apparently when someone decides to pay for it. Seems fair enough. No evidence yet that Satanists, Athiests, Humanists or Muslims have been told their money isn't good enough.

Reply
Adrian

We're a Christian country Jeff. Whether you like it or not and whether you're religious or not, our society has been built on the principles of the Judeo-Christian faiths. Other countries are available.

Reply
Fanny Hill

You wouldn’t think so, considering the self righteous bile spouted by far right “Christian Nationalists” trying to hijack Christ’s teaching to spread hatred.

Reply

In reply to Fanny Hill

Adrian

Christianity is by no means the only religion that spawns extremists - as recent history shows us.

Reply

In reply to Fanny Hill

hdavies15

Fanny get your blinkers off. I've yet to find a faith, religion or any other set of beliefs that doesn't have a set of fundamentalist cranks within it just spoiling for a "holy war" or some other similar madness.

Reply

In reply to hdavies15

Mab Meirion

Fanny get your gun...why do we celebrate so many executions...

Reply
Karl

Census says otherwise. We was Christian via the sword. So not Christian ironically

Reply
Paul ap Gareth

Wales is not a Christian country. It has not been a Christian country since the Church in Wales Act 1914 came into effect (in 1921 I think). This Act disestablished the state religion and left Wales as a secular country with no official religion.

Reply
Mab Meirion

Over the years Homo Superstitious has created, it is estimated, more than 100,000 gods!

Reply
Mab Meirion

Tell that to the Senedd, the place is cult central...totally out of order...

Reply
hdavies15

Hardly Christians despite them using that name. Fundamentalists of any kind of religion or belief are seriously dodgy, big mental health symptoms visible for those who choose to see. Check out the radical Islamists, Hindus, Buddhists, trans activists, green gospel ranters ...... Too many to list, all ravin' bonkers.

Reply
Mab Meirion

Are you familiar with Vance's branch of Catholicism, the many Christian Yeomanry Regiments are gathering into Brigades and Divisions under a Crusader flag. The Old Firm are adopting phallic symbols rather than the Cross and the Stake... Trwmp, Musk and Bezos must have serious issues...

Reply

In reply to Mab Meirion

Mab Meirion

So Vance is off to Rome, once, all roads led to Rome... The blond who has the male politicians both sides of the Atlantic wooing her is going to game the next Pope with Vance...you watch... (spot Steve Bannon for ten points and for UK political twitchers, keep your eyes open for Lammy, he is worth 50 points as a bird of another persuasion...)

Reply
Erisian

It should always be clear who is paying for any advertising. No matter what the message.

Reply
Mike

If the humanists want to put up some "there's no point to anything, do what you want" banners I'm sure Cardiff Council would gladly take their money in the same way that the Christians have paid for advertising

Reply
Llandudno boy

A bit rich for the "Humanists UK" to complain, after their campaign slogans on buses.

Reply
Susan Davies

Not really. Their adverts didn't have the logo on them implying that the local council endorsed the viewpoint, did they?

Reply
Adrian

It's Easter FFS!

Reply
Fanny Hill

“FFS!”? What a truly Christian response. Celebrating Easter with an egg hunt on Sunday?

Reply
Adrian

From where did you get the idea that I'm a Christian?

Reply

In reply to Adrian

Fanny Hill

Your reply to Jeff claiming we are a Christian country. Just assumed you were wearing your faith on your sleeve. Plus, I never thought of Adrian as a Jewish,Muslim Sikh or Hindu name, although I could be wrong. Off to church now, will say a prayer for you.

Reply
Mandi A

It's also Passover and Ramadan lasted through till the end of March ie. it was Ramadan through Lent

Reply
Susan Davies

What a breathtakingly naive response from Cardiff Council. How on earth can they deny that sticking their logo on something makes it look like they endorse it? Somebody in their comms team needs a refresher course!

Reply
Moses

I saw quite a lot of banners in the same vain during Ramadan presumably paid for by islamic charities. Has anyone seen the Humanists response to that?

Reply
Susan Davies

Did those banners have the council logo on? If not, then you've completely missed the point of the article.

Reply
Gareth Westacott

No, they wouldn't dare! But Christians are an easy target.

Reply
Karl

Yuck,better fictional characters exist. And certainly better supporters who are not fake

Reply
Keith Parry

Few weeks ago banners on lampposts in City Road urged people to praise Allah. Good to see some Christian banners. Nothing stopping Humanists paying for banners on Lampposts. Cardiff Council is skint having spent all its money on empty cycle lanes. So needs the money.

Reply
hdavies15

No doubt some fundamentalist cyclists will fund a "get on yer bike" message sometime soon, just to keep things interesting.

Reply
Mab Meirion

First they came for the 'Humanists'... Violence begets Violence, 2000 years to this very morning, the followers of the 3 books one god brigade are as ants, baked-in killers...

Reply
Mandi A

Testing, testing .... religion first, politics next. Next year Cardiff will be festooned with Reform banners, and any other group which sees such expensive publicity as a good use of its election expenses. Councils own a lot of public space and should be legally required to use it judiciously and respectfully. I would like nation.cymru to publish Cyngor Caerdydd's "overarching advertising policy" for our greater edification. Does it state that advertisers should name themselves on their own material? We want to know if there is a connection between the Senedd Prayer Breakfasts, the Leader of the Senedd Opposition's espousal of the Welsh religious revival movement and these Christian evangelical banners. "beyond setting the parameters of the overarching advertising policy, the council does not take decisions regarding individual campaigns where they are compliant with the standards articulated in the policy.”

Reply
Mandi A

A very quick search amongst Cardiff City Council's policy documents produced this guidance on exhibitions in public spaces. ". . . by its very nature an exhibition will involve the Council in the active promotion of the subject matter included in the display. Therefore in making decisions about the use of our publically accessible space the Council also needs to take into account its wider community cohesion and community safety responsibilities." "All information held by the Council is the subject of Freedom of Information and the Subject Access Requirements of the Data Protection Act." Exhibition Review Policy

Reply
Mandi A

Advertising on Council property You could benefit from advertising on over 500 highly visible, photographic quality banners located Cardiff city centre. Raised Lamppost Banners offer an unrivalled opportunity to project your message to shoppers, businesses, and visitors to the city with a conjoined footfall of over 40million each year. Raised Level Advertisements have a 2.5 times better memory recall rate than the same advert at ground level, meaning that your advertising spend works harder for you than other formats. If you’ve only got a small budget, there’s no need to worry! Raised Lamppost Banners are a flexible format which means you can have banners covering multiple locations across the city centre or just a few banners outside your venue or business to promote a particular event or promotion. Our quotes are always inclusive of production and installation costs, and we handle everything including providing expert advice to ensure your campaign gets the most standout and impact. Overall, the format represents a strong option for businesses looking to increase their visibility and reach in the city.

Reply
Mandi A

For clarity, this is from Cardiff Council's advertising pitch

Reply
Mandi A

For then shall burst on man's astonished eyes The Christian banner waving in the skies, Borne by angelic bands supremely fair, By countless seraphs through the pathless air. The heavenly sky shall Christ's proud banner form, A sky unruffled by a cloud or storm; The bloody cross aloft in awful pride Shall float triumphant o'er the airy tide. Goronwy Owen

Reply

Leave a reply

Replying to Mab Meirion Cancel

Are you familiar with Vance's branch of Catholicism, the many Christian Yeomanry Regiments are gathering into Brigades and Divisions under a Crusader flag. The Old Firm are adopting phallic symbols rather than the Cross and the Stake....

Comments are reviewed before they appear.