Fri, 31st July Cardiff 14°
Nation.Cymru wordmark
Advertisement

Culture

We asked an AI chatbot a series of questions about Wales and the Welsh

By David Owens
Red wall fans image by Welsh Government

David Owens

If you've been cryogenically frozen and only just woken up, then you would probably be unaware of how prevalent AI, or artificial intelligence to give it its full name, is becoming in our technologically advanced world.

AI assists in every area of our lives, whether we're trying to read our emails, get driving directions, get music or movie recommendations and using social media.

So before AI and the robots take over the world and do away with humanity for good, we thought we'd deploy an AI chatbot to answer a series of searching, contentious and downright flippant questions about Wales and its many varied facets.

From what does it mean to be Welsh and why is there a dragon on the Welsh flag to why do the Welsh love singing and what is more popular in Wales - football or rugby, these were a few of the questions we posed to the Chat GPT app.

So if you ever wanted to know which football club an AI chatbot thinks is the biggest in Wales or what are the most popular tourist destinations in this fair country, then read on. And while you're at it, let us know what you think of the answers and what questions you would ask. Thanks/Diolch!

[mid-content-banner]

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Get more trusted Welsh news

Choose Nation.Cymru as a preferred source in Google News to see more of our journalism.

Choose Nation.Cymru as a preferred source in Google News

5 comments

Mawkernewek

Can you write a short dialogue between Llewellyn ap Gruffydd and King Edward I about Welsh independence? ChatGPT: Llewellyn ap Gruffydd: Your Majesty, I come before you today to discuss the matter of Welsh independence. The people of Wales have long desired self-governance and the preservation of our culture and language. We seek recognition as a sovereign nation. King Edward I: Llewellyn, I understand your desire for independence, but it is my duty to ensure stability and unity within my kingdom. Wales has long been under the rule of the English crown, and I must consider the implications of granting independence. Llewellyn ap Gruffydd: Your Majesty, we do not seek to disrupt the peace or stability of the realm. We merely wish to govern ourselves and make decisions that are in the best interest of our people. Our history, culture, and language deserve preservation and recognition. King Edward I: Llewellyn, I respect your love for your land and people. However, the unity of our kingdom is paramount. The administration of Wales under the English crown ensures order and allows for efficient governance. I cannot grant independence without considering the potential consequences for both our nations. Llewellyn ap Gruffydd: Your Majesty, I implore you to reconsider. The Welsh people have endured centuries of subjugation, and we yearn for the freedom to determine our own destiny. With independence, we can foster stronger relations, cooperate as equals, and contribute to the greater prosperity of the realm. King Edward I: Llewellyn, I acknowledge your concerns and the aspirations of the Welsh people. Let us find a middle ground that respects both our interests. I propose granting Wales more autonomy within the kingdom, allowing for a greater say in local affairs and representation. This compromise would preserve unity while addressing some of your grievances. Llewellyn ap Gruffydd: Your Majesty, while I appreciate your willingness to consider a compromise, I must emphasize that true independence is what the Welsh people truly desire. However, I am open to discussing increased autonomy and representation as an interim solution. It is crucial that the voices and rights of the Welsh people are respected. King Edward I: Llewellyn, I appreciate your willingness to engage in dialogue. Let us work together to find a solution that serves the best interests of both our nations. Your passion for Wales is evident, and I believe through respectful negotiation, we can pave the way for a more harmonious future. Llewellyn ap Gruffydd: Thank you, Your Majesty. I am encouraged by your open-mindedness. Let us strive for a resolution that acknowledges the aspirations of the Welsh people and ensures their rightful place within the kingdom. Together, we can forge a path that respects the unique identity of Wales while maintaining the stability of the realm. King Edward I: Agreed, Llewellyn. Let us proceed with mutual respect and a shared goal of finding a sustainable solution. Our discussions shall pave the way for a brighter future, where both the English and Welsh can coexist as equal partners within our kingdom.

Reply
Philip Davies

The dead giveaway is the complete obliviousness of the bot to the portrayal of any plausible character of the real people who are supposed to be meeting. The cruel and ruthless Edward the 1st never ever said anything like 'Let us proceed with mutual respect'. The desperate historical Welsh struggle which was precipitated by Edward's intransigent and power-hungry militarism is nowhere seen in the chunterings of the brainless idiot which is the computer. Another giveaway is the failure of Edward as characterised here to acknowledge the Royal dignity of Llewelyn, who yet refers to Edward as 'Majesty' throughout as if already conquered; he was Edward's equal! As a dramatic dialogue, Saunders Lewis this ain't!

Reply
Riki

“Welsh” people didn’t exist until the late 1800s…up until the native British people of Wales (known as Cymric in their own language) were forced to speak English, which in turn created a situation where they would refer to themselves as “Welsh”. Leaving the title used by Rome to describe those native Britons to be used to describe the Anglo. A thousand year effort to take this island of its indigenous population and replace the Cymric man as the Briton with the Anglo man as the Briton.

Reply
Nia James

Definitely correct about the Swans!

Reply
Another Richard

The bot clearly has some catching up to do on Eryri and Bannau Brycheiniog.

Reply

Leave a reply

Replying to Mawkernewek Cancel

Can you write a short dialogue between Llewellyn ap Gruffydd and King Edward I about Welsh independence? ChatGPT: Llewellyn ap Gruffydd: Your Majesty, I come before you today to discuss the matter of Welsh independence. The people of...

Comments are reviewed before they appear.