Sat, 18th July Cardiff 18°
Nation.Cymru wordmark
Advertisement

Culture

Review: Bob Dylan at Swansea Arena

By Molly Stubbs
Bob Dylan performing at the Benicassim Festival in Spain. Photo Christian Bertrand / Shutterstock.com

Pierre Donahue 

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

It’s a wet November night in Swansea, and a crowd of Bob Dylan fans have gathered in anticipation at the Queens Hotel before the show.

Longtime enthusiasts trade stories over beer. “I saw him at the Isle of Wight Festival in 1969” says one. “He was in a white suit and had The Band backing him”. “I saw him in 1966 at the Capitol Theatre in Cardiff,” says another.

Dylan has had such an incredible career, ever since he hitched a ride to New York City in 1961 as the unknown Robert Zimmerman. His music stretches across the generations. He caught the zeitgeist of the times and he caught it good.

However the discussion tonight soon turns to what to expect of Bob Dylan in 2025? The consensus from the faithful: forget hoping to see Bob of the 60s and 70s. Those days are gone. Just enjoy it for what it is. I accept the challenge. And with that, we all drink up and excitedly head over to the arena.

At the grand old age of 84, Dylan could be forgiven for wanting to put his feet up and retire somewhere warm. But his tour schedule seems to defy that train of thought.

When asked why he still kept on relentlessly touring after five decades, his response? That he had agreed ‘something’ many years ago with the chief of this world and the next, and was merely keeping his side of the bargain. It’s not clear exactly with whom he bargained.

Tonight is the first of three sold-out shows at Swansea Building Society arena. It’s a great place to see a gig. With just 3,500 seats, it is relatively small by arena standards, but an impressive space nonetheless.

The lights suddenly go down. Bob takes the stage.

Now I have seen a lot of ‘legends’ perform, but there is something undeniably electrifying about being in Dylan’s presence. Perhaps it’s because he’s been around for so long, and reinvented himself so many times, that he’s now almost like some mythical beast.

These days Dylan sits at a piano. From where I’m seated all I can make out is his head with silver grey buffed-up hair, silhouetted from behind a light. I’d already been forewarned not to expect any interaction from him and this is clearly the case here. He launches into a somewhat unfamiliar version of ‘I’ll Be Your Baby Tonight’. It’s hard to make out, and it becomes apparent he is actually playing the guitar. The band quietly and pleasantly fills in behind him. It almost has the feel of a jam session. As if the song is being worked out as they play.

This approach continues into the set. Dylan turns to the piano and plonks along happily to his classic ‘It Ain’t Me Babe’. But any thoughts that it’s going to be a greatest hits set are quickly dismissed. The show heavily features tracks from his recent album Rough & Rowdy Ways. Almost unbelievably, his 39th album. Yes, he really has been around that long.

Halfway through the hour-and-forty-five minute set, and halfway through another somewhat meandering piano solo, I sense perhaps some in the audience are growing a little restless. It’s almost like Bob is playing with the band and also playing with us.

But moments of real magic pierce through. Like when he picks up the harmonica and gives it a little blow. In that moment my mind is immediately taken to footage I recently watched of him at the Royal Albert Hall in 1966. Dylan in his prime. This is a long way from that, but it appears he’s enjoying himself, and so am I. I can see his foot tapping.

The show ends and he stands up to rapturous applause. At his age, perhaps this is the last time I’ll ever get to see him. I am clapping as much, if not more, for his incredible body of work, as on this performance. There is no doubt he will be seen as one of, if not the all-time greatest songwriter the world has ever seen. It’s a moment to cherish.

Afterwards, we trudge through the damp streets back over to the Queens Hotel to debrief. It was just as they said it would be -- an experience. Dylan is Dylan and will be an enigma until the end. As the pub empties, someone gets up to the piano in the corner and starts to play ‘The Man In Me’ from his 1970 album New Morning. Soon there is a good old fashioned sing-along. His words are so universally appreciated and known that everyone can join in.

A true man of words. Just like another well known Dylan. Tonight both men came together in Swansea for the first time. I’m glad I was there to witness it.

Thanks for the music, Bob.

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Get more trusted Welsh news

Choose Nation.Cymru as a preferred source in Google News to see more of our journalism.

Choose Nation.Cymru as a preferred source in Google News

31 comments

Nia James

A good honest review. I was there last night and I was astonished how strong his voice is at 84. Over the decades I've seen Bob a dozen times. Yesterday was one of his finest performances. Keep on rocking Bob - one Dylan happy to be in another Dylan's city.

Reply
Baz

Flat out the worst concert I have ever seen. I don’t know how it could have been worse. Luckily, there was a busker outside playing Dylan hits and he was far more entertaining. Seriously, some unknown busker was better. I gave the guy £5 for rescuing the night. Dylan gets a hall pass because of his name. But Christ, his guitar and piano playing was horrific. His voice still sounds good but the concert was one long drone for two hours. The band were ok, but at the best of times, were sloppy. It just about got lifted out of misery by a few up beat blues songs, but these also lost energy eventually too. People in the audience were not happy! Give the people what they want. How about seeing as people paid hundreds to be there, that the band actually plays at least one or two hits. Man it was so bad.

Reply
Bill Scott

He did play a couple of his hits. His arrangements do differ but that is the beauty of Bob. the fact that the tour is called ‘The Rough and Rowdy’ tour should have given it away for you. I always take a look at the set list before I see a band. i thought the band were really tight and he was Bob Dylan, brilliant as expected!

Reply
Baz

He had his back turned for about half of the gig. Creating a lot of disconnection from the audience. So many duff notes and out of time playing. It was like watching a teenager band practice at points. He never bothered to say hello or goodbye, or engage with the people at all. I wasn’t expecting a greatest hits concert, but 2hrs is plenty of time for even two or three top listened plays. This was a money grab. Boring as hell. Sorry Bob…..but your hall pass doesn’t work anymore.

Reply
Phil

Sorry Bob, you’ve had a wonderful career and you have a fantastic body of work but last night was poor. I went with low expectations - but at least I’ll be able to say I’ve seen Bob Dylan…..with the way the stage was lit, I couldn’t swear on a holy book that I did. It effectively excluded the audience in my opinion. The whole show felt like we were there to pay homage. The busker also had a fiver off me, I wish he’d got the ticket price and Dylan the fiver.

Reply
Paul Seligman

It must be 15 or 20 years since we last went to see Dylan and that was in a college Sports Hall in Ventura California when we were visiting family. Sat on the bleachers and it was pretty much as you describe. In a word, dreadful. The man himself sat the back sideways onto the audience, with a hat covering his face playing keyboards. His performances had certainly deteriorated over the years but this was beyond forgiveness and we have never tried again.

Reply
tony greenstein

Yes I have to agree Baz. I've seen Dylan before at his 1978 Blackbushe concert and at Earls Court. I regret coming all the way from Brighton. It was just talking blues, nothing more. No melody. Yes he did 2 of his oldies - Desolation Row. I only knew it was Desolation Row since I know the lyrics but it sounded nothing like it. He massacred one of his finest songs, with its majestic haunting lyrics. It's all over now Baby Blue was not much better. Dylan didn't stand up, didn't engage with the audience. It's clear that his career is at an end but what a way to go. Why did he do this tour? It was a drag for him and us.

Reply
Bod

I wanted to see Bob as he'd come to my home town and I had grown up with his music always being around. I'd paid for myself and four members of my family to come to the gig too. We were sat in the front row and had the best view of him as he was facing sideways at the piano looking right at us. However anyone sitting five seats onwards to my left would have only seen a piano. . He at no time looked at the audience and when stood up as if to take the applause from faithful fans a few times he faced the back of the stage . I wanted to shout, "The audience is over here Bob" really weird. He scuttled on stage scuttled off without even a wave. People were hoping for an encore but men dressed as Bob, but Bob the builder came on to dismantle the equipment . I enjoyed it cos it was Bob Dylan but a hell of a lot of people would not have even caught a glimpse of him. Some of it was rough and out of tune . It was like watching some guys jamming in a living room. Strange gig but still glad I went.

Reply
Annie

My mum agrees the busker was the highlight of the night! She didn’t give him a fiver though the tight wad!

Reply
Bob Dylanwadwr

It's an album tour. Rough and Rowdy Ways. It was advertised as such. A great album. I don't understand people who buy something that has a particular label when they really want it to be something else, and then they complain about it. I thought it was awesome. Sure, there were a few bum notes. The song arrangements are complicated, and you're watching an 84 year old playing with them like they're toys. Many people don't even live to see 84. He's a creative genius that doesnt sit still and refuses to let people who live in the past to define him and hold him back. Perhaps you should listen to his albums, not just the hits (particularly if youve bought a ticket to see an album gig). Anyone who does so quickly realises that the vast majority of his work is incredible. Diolch, Bob - that concert blew my mind! Thank you for playing Swansea.

Reply
Elaine Griffiths

But he could still say hello and good bye and thank you for coming. Manners cost nothing!!

Reply
Jaqui

I asked my partner to come see him he declined to which I'm glad he passed away beginning of august and I'm glad he didn't see bob at his worst cos he loved dylan

Reply
Mab Meirion

An evening with Bob, talk about ungrateful, he hauls his ass all the way to Swansea, for Fans Sake...!

Reply
MrB

No body is ungrateful! He hauled his ass to Swansea for £160 of my Money. Now I didn't expect him to be dancing around the stage (he never has) but as a bare minimum, I did expect to see him, which I couldn't because of the rank awful stage lighting. I felt like I was about to be interrogated with the light placed behind him to silhouette his hair constantly in my eyes. It could have been anyone up there in a wig, I wouldn't have had a Scooby Doo cause I couldn't see. People can argue all they like that it was a good gig and die hard Dylan fans probably would. But the sad fact and the truth is.....It just wasn't. It was worse than poor! I agree with Phil, whoever he is!!

Reply
Mab Meirion

Was he in charge of the lighting...but I was on the IofW when he was, I spent 5 days and nights hitching there and back, walking from the ferry to the Hampshire border and all he did was get out of a helicopter, sing for an hour then fly off...Without a word now you mention it...The guy is staying one gig ahead of the grim reaper...

Reply
MrR

He wasn’t good, agree with everything you said. You should go and see the Counting Crows….now there’s a band!!

Reply

In reply to MrR

MrB

Thanks MrR for the recommendation. I'll have a look to see if they are on tour, ask my friends if they fancy it! I'm good like that!!

Reply
Disgruntled Donkey

Couldn't agree more. Absolute crock of ****. Zero interaction with the crowd. He has had a great career and his songs truly are a masterpiece, but that was awful.

Reply
Terry ap Hywel

I enjoyed Bob’s singing but I spent 2 hours looking at a few bright lights and shadows. They could have been playing a recording for all I knew. I was hoping to see him as well as hearing him. Very poor stage lighting and no big screen.

Reply
Nia James

That is the way that Dylan has been lighting his stage for many years, and there is very rarely a big screen at Arena events.

Reply
MrB

Were the other gigs a wake?

Reply
Dienw

I was there last night - I’ve been listening to Bob for 50 years and have nearly all his recordings. But it was a dreadful concert. He mumbled his way through, changing the melodies of even those songs whose lyrics I knew. It was very boring and ‘samey’. He sang most of the set list at the piano (we also had 2 purely instrumental pieces); the couple he played on the guitar, he had his back turned to the audience and his band crowded around him, protecting him from view. I thought he was bad when I saw him in Cardiff about 7 years ago, but this was even worse. The highlight for me was meeting Max Boyce and the busker singing Dylan on the way out.

Reply
Barbara

Intelligible Sound often unbalanced Stage in darkness

Reply
keith jackson

The reason I didnt go was partially my age, my economy and the awful sound repuation of the swansea arena....sorry but I'll live with my memories now while I can still rage against the dying of the day

Reply
Claire R

Absolutely terrible. From our seats couldnt make out which vague shadow on the stage might be Bob...the strip light was burning into my eyes and I felt like I was staring into a halogen heater....It could literally have been anyone up there claiming to be him and basically we paid £100 a ticket to NOT see Bob Dylan. I have been to over 100 gigs over the years and this is in the top 5 worst experiences. In the words of Johnny Rotten...'ever get the feeling you've been cheated?!' Also, If anyone knows how to contact his management team, please let me know!!!

Reply
Steve

Just been to this with my wife. Undeniably the worst £250 I have ever spent at a concert. Yes he is a legend but tonight he was no entertainer. My wife was never really aware of his works but now has the opinion he is a self absorbed old man with little charisma; sadly after tonight, I have to agree. Dreadfully disappointing and dull. He did not even say goodnight and thanks for the 1/2 million quid we spent to see him tonight.

Reply
Mike

I was there - at last I got to one of his gigs - and enjoyed the show but ….where was Bob? Hidden somewhere on stage possibly. Not the best of vocals but when was he ever and he is now 84, Self indulgent and impolite - no audience interaction whatsoever - no “hi” or “thanks for coming”, nothing!! Believe it or not I’m still glad I was there

Reply
Rayner Rees

I loved it and if any of the disgruntled folks had read the other reviews and paid attention to the title of the gig this is what it was . Rough and Rowdy Ways typical Bob.

Reply
Claire R

I guess you were'nt in the circle seat then!

Reply
Emma

Took my daughter to see him in Swansea on the 11th November for her 15th birthday treat. She absolutely loved Bob and his music. She was so excited to go see her idol. Paid for V.I.P tickets so was quite a huge chunk of my money spent taking her. Only for him to sit behind a grand piano all night and only stood up to turn his back for a couple of seconds. He did stand at the back of the stage for what seemed like less than a minute at the end. My daughter left in tears as she could not see him properly at that point with so many people standing up. He did not engage with the audience once for the whole 2 hours

Reply
Rosalind Mitchell

The first words I said to my husband when it ended was ‘ what a self-indulgent little f*** he is!’ You could hardly see him, if it was him? He ruined a couple of well-known songs. The rest just merged into the samey samey. I so wished I shouted out come on Bob we’re over here. Quite a lot of the audience obviously couldn’t see at all and so come and sat on the floor in the aisle near us. I wish I’d stayed at home and watched Coronation Street in the warm with a fish and chip supper.! You broke my heart Bob!

Reply

Leave a reply

Replying to Bill Scott Cancel

He did play a couple of his hits. His arrangements do differ but that is the beauty of Bob. the fact that the tour is called ‘The Rough and Rowdy’ tour should have given it away for you. I always take a look at the set list before I see a...

Comments are reviewed before they appear.