Wed, 22nd July Cardiff 21°
Nation.Cymru wordmark
Advertisement

Opinion

Llanelli – The voice of love and compassion you’re not hearing

By Mark Mansfield
Photo of a demonstration on June 4 about the use of Stradey Park Hotel for asylum seekers

There has been a voice missing in the local and national coverage of the protests surrounding the housing of refugees at Stradey Park Hotel, Llanelli – the voice of those standing up to the rise of fascism and racism to provide a place of sanctuary and peace for asylum seekers.

The stories and pictures of protestors objecting to the housing of asylum seekers in the hotel, holding signs saying “No Illegal Immigrants”, “All Lives Matter” and “No Nation of Sanctuary” have filled our local newspapers, national news and social media feeds for months.

Initially the protests grew out of concerns from the local community that were kept in the dark about the Home Office’s plans to turn the hotel into temporary accommodation for refugees, a community who had the decision thrust upon them with no consultation and no information.

However, the legitimate frustrations and concerns of local residents – let’s be clear this is a plan that doesn’t work for anyone, for the people losing their jobs of for the asylum seekers being housed in unsuitable housing - were soon hijacked by far-right groups to spread their agendas of fear, racism and aggression.

Over the past few months, we have seen racist and fascist groups Voice of Wales, and Patriotic Alternative descend on Furnace and Llanelli to spread their hate-filled rhetoric, and the town has received unwelcome visits from the Little Veteran and Katie Hopkins.

But throughout this there has been a strong voice for compassion, love and justice that has received little airtime.

Local people, supported by groups such as Stand up to Racism Llanelli, Hope not Hate and TUC Cymru, have countered demonstrations from the far right, standing just across the road from them in a show of peaceful defiance against their fascist messages. Holding placards of “Croeso” and “No Human is Illegal”, spreading kindness, and standing in solidarity with all those facing persecution.

[mid-content-banner]

Welcoming

These people are following Llanelli’s historical reputation as a welcoming community who fight for justice.

Llanelli has a diverse population, and like many industrial towns across South Wales, has benefitted from people migrating from across the world bringing their labour and skills to our industries and factories.

Llanelli became a new home to hundreds of refugees during the Second World War, and more recently, as the number of wars across the world increases, the town has provided sanctuary for families fleeing from Syria and Ukraine.

Llanelli is also a town with a strong history of working-class solidarity, and standing up for what is right. From the destruction of toll gates by the Rebecca Riots, to the 1911 Llanelli Railway Riots which saw hundreds of people strike and prevent the passage of trains through the station over low wages.

In the same year, 30 school children walked out of Bigyn School over the “unjustified” caning of a fellow pupil. In the late 1930’s four men from Llanelli fought with the International Brigade in the Spanish Civil War, fighting against fascism faced by others.

History proves that Llanelli is a strong community that rises in the face of adversity. It is important now to make sure its unshakeable resilience is not used for the wrong fight.

It is understandable to be angry at the loss of the hotel, which has been a long-standing community asset, and of course we are sad for our families, friends and neighbours who have lost their jobs. But this anger should not be turned towards families seeking sanctuary in our town.

Point this frustration at the Home Office and their cruel and illegal policies, to the owners of the hotel, Gryphon Leisure, for the heartless treatment of their staff and putting profit before people, and to the far-right groups who are hijacking this anger and frustration to push their hateful and divisive propaganda.

Helpless

So, for anyone in Llanelli reading this, who has felt helpless in the face of xenophobic messages being spread by far-right groups throughout the community, or has felt angry and upset at the way our town is being portrayed, you should know that you are not alone.

There is a strong community of people standing against this hate, combating the myths and lies from the far right, and working to create a peaceful and compassionate welcome for asylum seeking families.

You are with the majority, and when asylum seekers arrive, your kindness will be life changing for those seeking safety in our town.

We won’t let far right groups divide us, and we won’t let the Home Office’s inhumane policies create a rift in our community.

In an attempt to rebrand one of the anti-refugee protestors signs for good -  mae Llanelli a Ffoaduriaid yn gryfach gyda'i gilydd yn erbyn ffasgiaeth!

This article was submitted by a local resident who didn't want to be named for fear of possible repercussions.

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Get more trusted Welsh news

Choose Nation.Cymru as a preferred source in Google News to see more of our journalism.

Choose Nation.Cymru as a preferred source in Google News

17 comments

Cathy Jones

I needed to see this article today. To the people of Llanelli, you are loved.. and to those in Llanelli who are standing against racism and fascism, gratitude and admiration. There will be no fascism in Cymru. It will not be tolerated. If you adore Cymru and wish to preserve its culture, then check your history. Its not like there never has been nor isn't racism here, sadly there is, its just that we don't tolerate bullying in Cymru. As a nation, historically, Cymru has been the victim of bullying tactics, even today, Westminster uses bullying strategies against us. So although there are racists among us, it will not be tolerated. We know who the enemies of Cyru are, we know who are the ones who stole from us in the past and do so currently and plan to do even more so in the not-at-all-distant future. It's not the terrified people in a hotel surrounded by people who have been tricked and misled by bullies and con artists, ironically the brown person that IS stealing from us, that IS on the make, is the swine in Ten Downing Street, who was born and raised here amongst the rich white white people of England. Who boasted of having no working-class friends and of ensuring money ent to more affluent areas in England. Our enemies are not a racial group, it is the people who deprive us of equality, take away our rights, sell us out at every opportunity to line their own pockets, who allow Zaibatsu-Like corporations to write the tax laws, who cheat their expenses and accept dinner from "lobbyists". I kind of feel sad for those who think a bunch of terrified people in a Llabnelli hotel cn do more damage to their lives than the people who sit in Westminster like demons blind to their own sins passing law and legislature that allows workers rights to be erased and pollution to be pumped into our water, how blinded and broken and scared must they be?... However, I hope that any who break the law are dealt with mercilessly and I hope that all of them see how they are exploited and whose benefit they truly serve....

Reply
Mab Meirion

Slava Llanelli...

Reply
Tomi Benn

“We’ll keep a welcome…” Croeso! The people objecting to the asylum seeker families need to think about what COULD happen to their own descendants in the future. We MUST offer sanctuary and hope to the people who come to the Stradey Park Hotel.

Reply
CJPh

Diolch am yr erthygl - mae'r hanner gynta'n arbennig, bach rhy gwleidyddol a phleidgar yn r'ail hanner. S'dim rhaid i'r sefyllfa yma fod yn wleidyddol o gwbl. I've spoken to many people living in Llanelli, from Llanelli and born in Llanelli - nobody thinks that the situation at the hotel is ideal (ranging from "it isn't the best idea" to total opposition). As the beginning of this opinion piece states: "the legitimate frustrations and concerns of local residents – let’s be clear this is a plan that doesn’t work for anyone". That's the very pulse of the town encapsulated in a quote right there. As with any issue, it's more complicated than "for or against". Despite the unfortunate fact that there are indeed some locals attending the anti-immigration protests at the hotel (fewer, it seems, on the other side but still some), the leaders, organisers and the general thrust of their message doesn't seem very local. Indeed, it doesn't seem very Welsh. Neither does the other side, frankly. This whole affair goes to show that the culture wars, or the battle between the far Left and far Right benumbs the people of Wales and ignores the situation displaced peoples find themselves in, robbing them of basic humanity. Further, it highlights how the realpolitik approach of the British Left/neoliberals and the Union Jack-waving Right doesn't seem very 'real' in Wales. This whole affair truly highlights how different we are as a nation. My heart pushes me leftwards on this issue (indeed, on most issues - plus repetitious barks of "why are you betraying your country?" from the far-right hits me as quite ironic when they wave the butcher's apron and rub shoulders with people who openly detest our culture), but my head cannot abide the disingenuous nature of the narrative building, the sophistry and dirty tactics that often comes from the Left. One side puts feelings over facts, the other ignores feelings in place of facts (not both sets of loons at the Stradey Park - No facts, bad feelings down there). This is why I find my side (the Left) so repellent right now: ignoring feelings is a lack of compassion, ignoring facts is lying. Tying all that is good to the history of the Left, especially communism, is particularly galling. Stop being the other side of the dirty penny, it seems just as dehumanising as the far Right (despite not being as directly hostile to migrants) when using them as a political tool. Having said all that, it's really hard to get too enervated by this situation as a broader political issue, with our own freedom as a nation being at the very forefront for me. But human beings deserve a basic consideration as such, some rights are universal, and you cannot simply ignore what's going on around you. I'll welcome individuals from anywhere who find Wales as their new home whilst um-ing and ah-ing over the issue as a broader political topic - y'know, like almost everyone in Wales. In that spirit, this is how I see things panning out: many displaced people will end up in various parts of Wales over the next decade, some facing new hardships, some bringing problems, some met with compassion, some will simply go along to get along, but one thing is certain: after a little time, should they choose to stay here, they'll be accepted, treated with the same basic regard under the law as everyone else, and their children will be from here. Cymru grows, in every sense, just like we always have.

Reply
Padi Phillips

Unfortunately with the best will in the world the issue of migration is going to be or become one that is highly politicised as it always has been. It needs to be kept in mind that even a humanitarian approach, which is what you advocate does not exist in a political vacuum. However, I agree with you, the issue is being taken advantage of by both the right and the left, who, though marginally in the morally superior position, are still exploiting the issue for their own ends.. Where I have to somewhat disagree with you is where you seem to ignore the presence of home grown (i.e. Welsh) right-wing extremism. Voice of Wales is such a home-grown movement that needs to be both owned, and dealt with here in Wales. That's not to divert attention away from the presence of British fascists, as their role needs also to be highlighted and dealt with too, but I'm uncomfortable with their presence being allowed to dilute, or even mask the existence of home grown hate groups who have forged links with other dodgy movements such as the Qanon inspired Public Child Protection Wales.

Reply
CJPh

I wasn't clear enough in the second paragraph - Many of the locals there ARE standing side-by-side with the/are a part of the far right bloc, certainly. Many have come from out of town, but are still Welsh. I don't like playing "no true Welshman", but wouldn't a 10 question test on the 4 cainc, Dafydd ap, pre-industrial Welsh history and a few vocab Cymraeg questions be fun to conduct. I;d imagine quite a few zeroes from the "Why are you betraying your country" crowd... then again, that'd be 80% of the whole country anyway! Still, they're talking the talk and all that. On the Left's relative moral superiority - I'm not so sure anymore. The rhetoric certainly tends towards that, but the Right see the "others" as exactly that - "others we don't like because they are other", typically with disgust. At worst, much of their rhetoric tends towards describing the "other" as akin to animals. The fringe Left sees them as a device, a set of numbers. It's why we've seen an increase in de-personalised language in contemporary Leftists rhetoric: "Folx", "Black and Brown bodies", "The Global South", all eschewing where the Left used to always be (in the West), which was always focused on cultures and distinctions. The vanguard has set a moronic drum beat, nowhere near enough from amongst the reasonable are calling them out. It all feels a bit Maoist, don't you think Padi?

Reply

In reply to CJPh

Padi Phillips

Well, given the way social media has affected the way people think, yes, it does seem very driven by cliques who cynically exploit any and all causes as a way to promote their agenda. It all reminds me of the sort of antics the Socialist Worker students I met at university in the mid 80s. I'll always remember a poster I saw: some wag had managed to get a blank Socialist Worker poster and upon it he had written in bold letters 'Do these wankers even care?' About the left's moral superiority, I used the word supposed, but maybe that wasn't sufficient to suggest that I have my doubts - but you understood my drift, and yes, it's usually just rhetoric. You are of course quite right in saying that the idiot left, (as I call them) need to be called out. YesCymru managed to do that, but not before the idiot left had almost destroyed the movement. I suspect the reasons why people don't call them out is fear of the backlash from such groups. We all know what happened in the process of removing the idiot left in control of YC. They eventually vacated, but that was after a bitter period of recrimination and of accusations of acts and attitudes that simply weren't there. We're living in strange times, and we still aren't completely sure how powerful social media is, just that it's powerful. I've recently read Miles Taylor's Blowback about the chaotic presidency of Trump and how utterly dangerous he is, but more importantly how there are far more in control contenders waiting in the wings who won't be as incompetent, stupid and chaotic as Trump and how they need to be countered. Of course, the book is predominantly about the USA, but it won't have escaped you that there are mini Trumps all over Europe who are gaining power and influence using exactly the same tactics as the MAGA Republicans in the USA, except worryingly with little serious pushback. I'm now reading The Other Pandemic: How QAnon Contaminated the World by James Ball. It's an interesting read, and is predominantly about how the extreme right manipulates and uses social media for its own ends, but all of it is equally applicable to the extreme left/idiot left. Yes, it does feel a little Maoist, now you come to mention it!

Reply

In reply to Padi Phillips

CJPh

However one sees QAnon, either as largely a USGov psyop to justify crackdowns or an actual grassroots movement of ultra-right conspiracy-fuelled pop fascists (or, most likely in my opinion, a bit of both), neither is good. It has, as with 'Woke' for the far right and 'N*zi' for the far left, become a simple pejorative. These ideas are important to understand, but easy to slip into fuzzy logic and linguistic usurpation - this is why my comments on these boards are so long winded. I do not want to be misunderstood, where that seems to be the goal with others. This is far more pervasive on the far Left - indeed, it has always been a part of the Left, with the wolf in sheep's clothing featuring prominently on the Fabian Window at LSE, for instance. It is not, however, simply the uncouth nature or immorality in obfuscation that I don't like. It's also woefully counterproductive (hopefully that statement proves I'm more Left than Right, despite being called far right quite a few times here on Nation). Take the application of the F-word: when 'fascism' can solely be defined as "whatever I, quintessential Leftist, disagree with", or even more vapidly "bad stuff", or terrifyingly "Whatever the people on the telly/internet/newspaper says it is", then we run the risk of seeing it actually re-emerge (or have already seen it - Dugin's Eurasianism in Russia, Chairman Xi's new thought, the Public/Private partnership model of "stakeholder capitalism" - which is basically Fascist Bolshevism - and the new definition of "Christian Nationalism", also called 'foundationalism' in the US...I know, these people don't read enough to understand that term already exists). Alongside the endless march to the top of the hill holding a greasy pendulum be the far Left, this is a failure of Liberalism. Although I hold some hope in my heart for a Liberal renaissance (Cymru would be a nice place for it to begin), I cannot see the spark igniting anywhere. Just a lot of darkness. Luckily, the superordinate goal of Welsh independence is quite separated from all this rubbish, and we seem to have kept it from pulling down our movement. Vigilance is vital, but I think we're going to be OK. This Anglo-American-Germanic-Frenchery doesn't play all that well in these parts.

Reply
Llyn

The use of hotels to house asylum seekers is a policy of the UK Conservative government (given the circumstances I understand why hotels are being used). Therefore, wouldn't it be nice if the leader of the Welsh Conservatives, someone who constantly attacks others for not taking responsibility, had the moral backbone to go down to Llanelli and defend his party's policies and those legally working in the hotel from vile attacks, instead of pathetically leaving it to others in the community to pick up the pieces.

Reply
Nobby Tart

He is indeed conspicuous by his absence. Some months ago, he visited his Conservative councillors in Swansea and put out one of his tweets praising them for "holding Swansea Council to account". Big Brave RT taking on a local council. He should be down Llanelli way, praising this policy between the Conservative Government and a private enterprise.

Reply
Steve Duggan

I totally agree with the article - these are people seeking help and refuge and the far right racist bigots have no place in Llanelli, which has always been an open, warm, welcoming place. The UK government thrives on sowing division, hoping it'll be a vote winner. It needs to know it's not going to work in Llanelli.

Reply
Washington Tomas

Had more than enough of this nonsense now. Almost like a make work programme for journalists. If we are a ‘nation of sanctuary’ then that’s what we are. If not then make it a political issue and stand against candidates who support that in the next Senedd election.

Reply
Conor MacDonald

This is a sorely needed article, and I’m sure I speak for many when I offer thanks to the anonymous author.

Reply
Arthur Owen

I am glad none of the racists hail from Llanelli,perhaps this is true.

Reply
Meg

At this stage, we can pretty much predict the demographic of all these anti-this and anti-that demonstrations. Down to the prevailing age, gender, brand of shorts and flip-flops, stomach girth, political alignment, Social media platform of choice, stance on royalty and whether or not to "support are buoys", all the way to least favourite religion and favourite online "news" website. They just get minibused in to whichever contentious hotspot they can find. If somebody does a drag queen story hour reading at Tenby library, I suspect the same dozen protestors would be there "pertecktin are kids"

Reply
Y Cymro

Yes you can protest as shown by those on South Pembrokeshire when the then Home Secretary Priti Patel bypassed the Welsh Government , Senedd & Pembrokeshire council by placing over 300 asylum seekers in a dank army camp at the height of Covid. without consultation, proper PPE supplies only then to move them out and later cynically billing locals the cost of housing them. The same is occuring again where another fascist Home Secretary Suella Braverman is also bypassing the Welsh Government, Senedd Cymru and concerned locals. And it doesn't help when flames are fanned by Britain First who have buses supporters in as done in Pembrokeshire to spout their bilious hatred. And as others have stated. Those ugly scenes filmed recently played on social media are a micro minority of morons, bigots & self-hating racists. They are not representative those decent people in Llanelli also protesting not out of hated towards those asylum seekers but concern for their community, cost of housing them, and conditions of those fleeing oppression being dehumanised by this corrupt Conservative idocracy in Whitehall.

Reply
cablestreet

Absolutely agree with this article. Stella Braverman's sheer incompetence in dealing with this situation has landed Llanelli with an influx of far right, and, to put mildly, undesirables who claim, amongst other things that there will be an increase in criminal activity in the area and our streets won't be safe to walk on when the asylum seekers finally arrive. Well surprise, surprise its already happened, 17 arrests of mainly far right protestors, including one for carrying three knives, with more probably to follow and not a single asylum seeker in sight. A visit to this link will give an insight as to what the Home Office, Gryphon Leisure and Clearsprings have collectively landed on our doorstep. https://hopenothate.org.uk/2023/07/20/far-right-seek-to-exploit-campaign-against-asylum-seekers-accommodation-in-llanelli/

Reply

Leave a comment

Comments are reviewed before they appear.